PREVALENCE OF THE FEMALE ATHLETE TRIAD IN EDIRNE, TURKEY
|
Trakya University, Faculty of Medicine, Departments of Physiology1,
Psychiatry2 and Nuclear Medicine3 and Kırkpınar School
of Sports and Physical Education4, Edirne, Turkey.
| Received |
|
31 August 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
14
October 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
December 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 550
- 555
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of the female athlete
triad, which is a clinical condition defined as the simultaneous occurrence
of disordered eating, amenorrhea, and osteopenia and/or osteoporosis
in female athletes. A total number of 224 female athletes from Edirne
city participated in our study. Eating attitudes test (EAT 40) and
a self-administered questionnaire were used to assess disordered eating
behavior and menstrual status respectively. The participants having
both disordered eating and amenorrhea were performed dual energy x-ray
absorptiometry to evaluate bone mineral density. Thirty seven subjects
(16.8%) had disordered eating behavior and 22 subjects (9.8%) were
reported to have amenorrhea. Six athletes (2.7%) met two criteria
(disordered eating and amenorrhea) of the triad. Of these, only three
athletes met all components of the triad. We have found that the prevalence
rate of female athlete triad was 1.36% among young Turkish female
athletes. Female athletes have under considerable risk for the disordered
eating and amenorrhea components of the triad.
KEY
WORDS: Amenorrhea, disordered eating, osteoporosis, osteopenia,
anorexia nervosa.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Over
the past century, there has been an exponential increase in the
number of female athletes both for competitive and/or recreational
facilities. Besides many beneficial effects of exercise, female
athletes are susceptible to disordered eating behavior, amenorrhea,
and osteoporosis. The constellation of these three clinical conditions
was defined as the female athlete triad by the American College
of Sports Medicine (Nattiv et al., 1994;
Otis et al., 1997;
Yeager et al., 1993).
Not only elite athletes but also physically active girls and women
have been accepted to be at risk of developing one or more components
of the triad (Otis et al., 1997;
West, 1998;
Golden, 2002).
Amenorrhea was reported to range from 1% to 44% in the female athletes
(De Souza, 2003).
The reported prevalence of disordered eating in some collegiate
and elite athletes was found equal to or higher than the general
population (Otis et al., 1997).
The occurrence of disordered eating behavior was reported in 15
to 62 percent of female athletes (Beals and Manore, 2002;
Dummer et al., 1987,
Rosen et al., 1986,
Sundgot-Borgen, 1994).
Although several studies reported that prevalence of one or two
components, only one study documented the prevalence of the triad
as a whole among female soldiers and did not find any subjects who
met the whole criteria of the triad (Lauder et al., 1999).
In this study, our aim was to investigate prevalence of the female
athlete triad in young Turkish female athletes from different branches.
|
| METHODS |
|
The
current prevalence study consists of a cross-sectional analysis.
The study was approved by the local ethics committee of Trakya University
and carried out between February and June, 2004. Details of the
study were explained to each subject, and informed consent was obtained
from the participants, and the parents of those who were younger
than 18 year old.
Subjects
Two hundred and twenty-four female athletes participated to the
study in the city of Edirne, Turkey. The ages of all subjects ranged
from 16 to 25 years. Participants were recruited from regional sport
clubs, high schools, and university sports teams of different branches.
Branch distribution was as follows: basketball (n = 79, 35.3%),
handball (n = 17, 7.6%), running (n = 26, 11.6%), swimming (n =
25, 11.2%), rhythmic gymnastics (n = 2, 0.9%), wrestling (n = 6,
2.7%), tennis (n = 4, 1.8%), volleyball (n = 40, 17.9%), taekwondo
(n = 16, 7.1%), and dancing (n = 9.4%). Athletes using oral contraceptives
were excluded from our study, because oral contraceptive use is
known to regulate the menstrual cycle. All subjects were nulliparous.
Questionnaire
A self-administered questionnaire was used to assess age, weight,
height, beginning age to sports, training regimen, menstrual status,
and history of fractures. Subjects were asked detailed questions
about their current menstrual status, frequency and regularity of
menstrual cycles. Eumenorrhea was defined as menstrual cycles occurring
every 28-30 day and lasted in this regular cycle for at least 12
months. Menstrual irregularity was used to describe irregular cycle
lengths (cycles not occurring every 28-34 days) (Beals and Manore,
2002).
The presence of primary amenorrhea was regarded as the absence of
menstruation by the age of 16 (ASRM Practice Committee, 2004;
Otis et al., 1997).
Secondary amenorrhea was regarded as absence of menstrual bleeding
following at least three or more consecutive menstrual cycles after
menarche (ASRM Practice Committee, 2004;
Otis et al., 1997).
Body mass index (BMI) was calculated as weight in kilograms per
height in square meter.
Eating Attitudes Test (EAT-40)
Disordered eating behaviors were assessed by the EAT-40 which is
a widely used, standardized, and self-reported questionnaire designed
to assess pathological eating behaviors, attitudes, and thoughts
(Garner and Garfinkel, 1979).
A Turkish translation, reliability and validity of this test were
performed in a group of sample consisting Turkish subjects (Erol
et al., 1989).
Response options ranging from "1 = always" to "6
= never", with higher scores indicative of clinical levels
of disordered eating. The scores, which were equal to and higher
than 30, were regarded as having disordered eating behaviour (Erol
et al., 1989).
The participants having both amenorrhea and disordered eating behaviour
were invited to psychiatric interview. All psychiatric interviews
were performed by the same psychiatrist (EV) using DSM-IV research
criteria (APA, 1994).
Bone densitometry
Dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) was performed to evaluate
bone mineral density. As the primary aim of our study was to investigate
the prevalence of all criteria of the Triad, we performed DEXA only
on the athletes, who met the two criteria of the triad. Areal bone
density was measured using DEXA (Norland XR36, Norland Medical Systems
Inc., Fort Atkinson, USA). DEXA scans were taken of the lumbar spine
(anteroposterior and lateral, L2-L4) and femoral neck. In our laboratory,
the coefficient of variation values for BMD were estimated to be
1.0% (lumbar L2-4 spine), 1.2% (femoral neck).
Blood analysis
The subjects having all criteria of the female athlete triad underwent
blood analyses. Blood samples were collected from a peripheral vein
in a resting state to determine the endocrine profiles including
TSH, FSH, LH, progesterone, prolactin, estradiol, DHEA-S and cortisol
measurements (Chemiluminescent Immunoassay System BioDPC, Euro/DPC
Ltd United Kingdom).
Statistical
analysis
Values were given as the mean ± SD. Chi-square method was performed
to evaluate relationships between nominal variables and Student's
t test was used for continuous variables. A p-value of below 0.05
was considered to be significant.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Menstrual
irregularities and amenorrhea
Amenorrhea was present in 22 (9.8%) of all athletes. Of the 22 athletes,
two (0.9%) reported primary amenorrhea. Both of the atheletes who
were reported primary amenorrhea were 16 years old, engaging in
rhythmic gymnastics and EAT-40 scores of these subjects are not
higher than the cutt of the EAT-40 score. They met only amenorrhea
component of the triad. The remaining 20 reported secondary amenorrhea.
Menstrual irregularity was reported by 43 (19.2%) of the athletes.
Eighty percent of all participating athletes (n = 181) reported
regular menstrual cycles during the past year. Athletes with irregular
menstrual cycle had lesser body weight and BMI with respect to eumenorrheic
group (Table 1). There were
no differences in EAT-40 test scores, age, height, participation
age to sports, duration of training and amount of training between
the athletes having eumenorrhea and menstrual irregularity (Table
1).
Disordered eating
Four athletes completed EAT-40 questionnaire improperly and were
excluded from the study. Eventually, 220 subjects were available
for further investigation. High EAT-40 scores were reported by 37
athletes (16.8%). Within the high EAT-40 group, 6 subjects (16.2%)
reported amenorrhea, whereas in the normal EAT-40 group, 14 subjects
(7.7%) reported amenorrhea (Chi-square p<0.05). Six athletes
(2.7%) met disordered eating and amenorrhea criteria of the triad
(Figure 1).
Psychiatric evaluation was made for the six athletes, whose EAT-40
scores were high, and who had amenorrhea. Two of these athletes
were diagnosed with having eating disorders. One of these athletes
met the diagnosis of anorexia nervosa. She was found to be in remission
during psychiatric interview. The other one was diagnosed to have
eating disorders not otherwise specified (EDNOS). The remaining
four athletes did not have the diagnostic criteria for anorexia
nervosa, bulimia nervosa or EDNOS.
Athletes with high EAT-40 scores had higher body weight (59.8 ±
7.6) than those with normal EAT-40 scores (56.5 ± 7.0 p < 0.02).
Bone mineral density
Six athletes, who had two criteria (disordered eating and amenorrhea)
of the triad, underwent DEXA scans to assess bone mineral density.
Consequently we identified the subjects with BMD diagnostic criteria
defined by Word Health Organization (Kanis, 2000).
Osteoporosis is defined as bone mass more than 2.5 SD below the
mean normal peak bone mass. Osteopenia is defined as bone mass that
ranges between 1.0 and 2.5 SD. BMD level of the 3 subjects were
within osteoporotic (n = 1) or osteopenic (n = 2) limits (Table
2).
Blood
analyses
Blood analyses were performed in the six athletes, who had whole
criteria of the triad. Only one of these athletes' FSH/LH ratio
changed in favor of LH (FSH, 6.99 mlU·ml-1, LH 12.9 mlU·ml-1)
and she had complaint about hirsutism. This finding suggested polycystic
ovary syndrome. In order to find a reason for amenorrhea, a detailed
gynecologic investigation was made, and this inquiry verified the
diagnosis of polycystic ovary syndrome. The laboratory results of
the remaining five athletes did not make us consider any explanations
(hypotroidi, hyperprolactinemia or Cushing syndrome, etc) to clarify
the reasons for amenorrhea.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
We
found the prevalence rate of the triad as 1.36% in our study population.
Although, it was suggested that the symptoms of the triad decrease
physical performance, and increase the potential risk for considerable
morbidity and mortality, little is known about the prevalence of
all symptoms of female athlete triad (Otis et al., 1997).
Only one prevalence study was investigated the whole criteria of
the triad, and it was not found any women, who met whole symptoms
of female athlete triad in the female soldiers (Lauder et al., 1999).
We determined all symptoms of the triad in three athletes in our
study. One of these athletes had both diagnosis of polycystic ovarian
syndrome and anorexia nervosa. She reported that her symptoms had
begun after intensive exercising period when she was 16 years old.
Since amenorrhea of this athlete could not only be ascribed to the
polycystic ovarian syndrome but also to the anorexia nervosa, we
regarded her as an athlete who met the symptoms of the female athlete
triad in this study.
Kuğu et al. (2002)
investigated prevalence of eating disorder among 980 Turkish university
students using EAT-40 and they reported that 7.4% of the subjects
were above the cut off point. We found disordered eating behavior
in 16.8% of the study group. Furthermore, athletes with high EAT-40
scores had higher body weight than the athletes with normal EAT-40
scores in our study. Cobb et al. (2003)
showed similar results, and they suggested that heavier women were
more inclined to eating disorders, because they were more dissatisfied
with their natural body type.
Menstrual irregularity is a common condition among female athletes.
For instance, as many as two- thirds of runners who have menstrual
periods have short luteal phases or are anovulatory (De Souza et
al., 1998).
However, most of the studies on female athlete triad accepted solely
amenorrhea rather than oligomenorrhea or other irregularities as
one of the criteria of the triad (Anderson, 1999;
Donaldson, 2003;
Golden, 2002;
Nattiv et al., 1994;
Otis et al., 1997;
Putukian, 1998)
. Furthermore, DSM-IV research criteria of eating disorders include
only amenorrhea (APA, 1994).
In the light of above literature, we preferred amenorrhea as a definition
criterion.
We measured bone mineral density of six athletes, who had disordered
eating and amenorrhea and found osteoporosis in one athlete and
osteopenia in two athletes in our study. Thus, we detected osteoporosis
or osteopenia in the half of the athletes, who met the two criteria
of the triad. Osteoporosis was described as one of the three criteria
of the triad in many publications (Golden, 2002;
Otis et al., 1997).
However, Khan et al. (2005)
suggested that osteopenia could be defined among the criteria of
female athlete triad syndrome because osteporosis was rare and osteopenia
in a young athlete may provide a worse prognosis for bone health
of this athlete. In addition, significant osteopenia that is, T-
score of -2.0, in a twenty year old may lead to a worse prognosis
for long term bone health than osteoporosis in a 65 year old with
a T-score of -2.6 (Khan et al., 2005).
Therefore, we regarded osteopenia as one of the criteria of the
triad in our study.
There are several limitations that deserve comment. In our study,
the EAT-40 was used as an initial screening tool, and individual
psychiatric interviews were performed with athletes, who met the
two criteria of triad to rule out false-positive results. Unfortunately,
the true false-negative rate could not be determined through our
study, because all women were not interviewed. It was known from
previous studies that EAT-40 might give 2-3% false-negative result
(Rodrigez-Cano, 2005).
On the other hand, our study did not show any prevalence for all
subjects in terms of osteoporosis and/or osteopenia of the triad.
However, this study showed the frequency of osteoporosis or osteopenia
of the subjects who have the two components of the triad.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| In
conclusion, the prevalence rate of the triad was 1.36% in our study.
In addition, prevalences of disordered eating and amenorrhea were
16.8% and 9.8% respectively in our study population. We believe that
further investigation of the prevalence of all components of the triad
in larger groups is needed, with which our results can be compared. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- The
prevalence rate of the occurrence of whole criteria of the female
athlete triad was 1.36 % in young Turkish athletes in Edirne.
- Female
athletes who met whole criteria of female athlete triad are more
prone to the eating disorders.
- The
occurrence of disordered eating behavior was higher in female
athletes according to general population.
- Amenorrhea
prevalence was significantly higher in female athletes who had
disordered eating.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Selma Arzu VARDAR
Employment: Ass. Prof., Depart. of Physiology Trakya University.,
Edirne, Turkey
Degree: MD, PhD.
Research interests: The cardiovascular effects of melatonin,
women and exercise, the effect of exercise on sleeping.
E-mail: arzuvardar@trakya.edu.tr |
|
Erdal VARDAR
Employment: Assoc. Prof., Department of Psychiatry, Trakya
University, Edirne, Turkey.
Degree:MD.
Research interests: Eating disorders, alcohol and anabolic
steroid abuse and dependence.
E-mail: erdalvardar@trakya.edu.tr |
|
Gülay DURMUS-ALTUN
Employment: Ass. Prof., Departments of Nuclear Medicine
and Physiology, Trakya University, Edirne, Turkey.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Nuclear cardiology, osteoporosis
and exercise.
E-mail: gdurmusaltun@trakya.edu.tr |
|
Cem KURT
Employment: Trakya University Kırkpınar School of Sports
and Physical Education, Edirne, Turkey
Degree: MSc.
Research interests: Plyometric exercise.
E-mail: cemkurt@hotmail.com
|
|
Levent ÖZTÜRK
Employment: Assoc. Prof., Departments of Physiology, Trakya
University, Edirne, Turkey
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Sleep physiology, sleep and exercise
interactions, sleep related breathing disorders.
E-mail: leventozturk@trakya.edu.tr
|
|
|
|
|