|
EFFECT OF CAFFEINE ON OXIDATIVE STRESS DURING MAXIMUM INCREMENTAL
EXERCISE
|
1Department of Didactics of Music, Plastic and Corporal Expression,
Sport Science Faculty, University of Extremadura, Cáceres, Spain
2Department of Physiology, Sports Sciences Faculty, University of Extremadura,
Cáceres, Spain
3Department of Pharmacology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Extremadura,
Badajoz, Spain
4Department of Analytical Chemistry and Electrochemistry, Sciences Faculty,
University de Extremadura. Badajoz, Spain
5Department of Physiology. School of Physiotherapy. University of Valladolid.
Soria, Spain.
| Received |
|
11 April 2006 |
| Accepted |
|
02
October 2006 |
| Published |
|
15
December 2006 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2006) 5, 621 - 628
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Caffeine
(1,3,7-trimethylxanthine) is an habitual substance present in a wide
variety of beverages and in chocolate-based foods and it is also used
as adjuvant in some drugs. The antioxidant ability of caffeine has
been reported in contrast with its pro- oxidant effects derived from
its action mechanism such as the systemic release of catecholamines.
The aim of this work was to evaluate the effect of caffeine on exercise
oxidative stress, measuring plasma vitamins A, E, C and malonaldehyde
(MDA) as markers of non enzymatic antioxidant status and lipid peroxidation
respectively. Twenty young males participated in a double blind (caffeine
5mg·kg- 1 body weight or placebo) cycling test until exhaustion. In
the exercise test, where caffeine was ingested prior to the test,
exercise time to exhaustion, maximum heart rate, and oxygen uptake
significantly increased, whereas respiratory exchange ratio (RER)
decreased. Vitamins A and E decreased with exercise and vitamin C
and MDA increased after both the caffeine and placebo tests but, regarding
these particular variables, there were no significant differences
between the two test conditions. The results obtained support the
conclusion that this dose of caffeine enhances the ergospirometric
response to cycling and has no effect on lipid peroxidation or on
the antioxidant vitamins A, E and C.
KEY
WORDS: Trimethylxanthine, malonaldehyde, vitamins, catecholamines,
VO2 max.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Caffeine,
or 1,3,7- trimethylxanthine, is a widely used substance present
in habitual beverages and chocolate-based foods and is also used
for therapeutic purposes, being present in a wide variety of fixed
combination prescription drugs. Moreover, caffeine is used as an
ergogenic aid because multiple well-controlled experiments have
found that moderate doses of caffeine (3-6 mg/kg) can improve performance
in athletes (Graham, 2001,
Flinn et al., 1990).
Its use by athletes is actually favoured since the International
Olympic Committee (IOC) has recently removed caffeine from its list
of banned substances.
The ergogenic effect of caffeine ingestion before
exercise has been reported above all in high intensity aerobic conditioning
programs (Bruce et al., 2000;
Jackman et al., 1996;
Wiles et al., 1992).
The mechanism for the caffeine-improved performance is not clear
but several possibilities have been proposed such as the antagonism
of adenosine receptors (Davis et al., 2003),
the attenuation of effort perception or reduction of muscle pain
(Doherty et al., 2004;
O'connor et al., 2004) and the increase in catecholamine release (Greer et al.,
2000; Graham et al., 2000; Jackman et al., 1996; Van Soeren et al., 1993).
Some of these caffeine-derived effects could favour the production
of free radicals and a subsequent increase of oxidative stress such
as the metabolic inactivation of catecholamines (Halliwell and Gutteridge,
1985; Jewett et al., 1989) and the increase of oxidative metabolism (Shigenaga et
al., 1994; Thompson et al., 2001) including its own hepatic metabolism (Vistisen et al.,
1992). There are also reports suggesting that caffeine is capable
of inducing certain forms of oxidative damage by increasing lipid
peroxidation (Dianzani et al., 1991)
Nevertheless, caffeine has been reported as a protective substance
on cellular damage (Kamat et al., 2000; Krisko et al., 2005) with beneficial antioxidant effects (Nikolic et al.,
2003); probably due to the main metabolites of caffeine, 1-methylxanthine
and 1-methyluric acid, that are highly effective antioxidants and
are able to prevent LDL oxidation in vitro (Lee, 2000).
So, what will be the behaviour of caffeine with regard to maximum
aerobic effort? Will caffeine protect the organism from the deleterious
effects of free radicals which are generated in these situations,
or on the contrary, will caffeine act as a pro-oxidative substance
by increasing cellular damage?
The present study examines the effect of caffeine on certain biomarkers
of antioxidant status such as vitamins A, E and C and on a marker
of lipid peroxidation such as malonaldehyde (MDA), in order to identify
caffeine's role regarding oxidative stress in an incremental cycling
test until exhaustion.
|
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
Participants were twenty young males who reported no caffeine consumption
and who were not regularly performing exercise. The subject did
not receive any vitamin or antioxidant supplementation before or
during the study. They were informed of the procedure of this study
and they all gave written consent. The participants' characteristics
are provided in Table 1 and
values were calculated using cineanthropometric techniques.
Experimental design
Caffeine was administered using a single dose, double-blind and
randomised procedure to protect against possible subject motivation.
On the day of the experiment, the participants ingested capsules
that contained caffeine (5mg·kg-1 body weight) or a placebo with
water. One hour later they cycled until exhaustion on a cycle ergometer
(Ergo-metrics 900 de Ergo-line®). The starting intensity for the
test was set at 100 Watts and was increased by 50 Watts every two
minutes until 300 Watts, when it was increased by 25 Watts until
exhaustion. Expired gases, ventilation and heart rate were measured
using a Medical Graphics gas analyser (MGC, model nº 762014-102)
and a hear rate monitor (Polar ® S 720) with interface (Polar ®
Advantage interface). Each subject performed the cycling test under
two conditions, placebo and caffeine, with an interval of three
days in order to favour recovery and to remove exercise adaptations.
This research has been performed with the permission of legal and
ethical committees in Spain.
Measurements
A blood sample was obtained from the anticubital vein in repose
conditions before caffeine (or placebo) ingestion and immediately
after the exercise. Haematocrite determination was made by microcentrifugation
(Microcentrifugue Alresa) of 25 µl of blood contained in heparinised
capillars, in order to correct the oxidative markers measured in
blood due to a possible hemoconcentration. Plasma was obtained by
centrifugation and was stored at -20oC until use, which was not
longer than one week. Plasma samples were analysed by HPLC to determine
the concentrations of vitamin A and E (Shearer, 1986) as lipid soluble no-enzymatic antioxidants, vitamin C
(Manoharan and Schwille, 1994) as water soluble no enzymatic antioxidant and MDA (Esterbauer
et al., 1984) as a measure of lipid peroxidation.
A urine sample was obtained in repose conditions before caffeine
(or placebo) ingestion in order to guarantee no previous caffeine
consumption and immediately after the exercise. Caffeine was determined by HPLC (Spectra SERIES P100 / UV 100)
(Dobrocky et al., 1994).
Statistics
Statistical analysis was performed on SPSS version 11.0, performing
the two way Anova test, in which the within group factor corresponds
to the ergometer test and the inter group factor corresponds to
the caffeine effect. A p value of < 0.05 was used to determine
statistical significance.
|
| RESULTS |
|
A comparison of the ergospirometric values between
both tests (Table 2) showed
that subjects in the caffeine trial cycled longer, supported more
load, and their heart rate and relative oxygen consumption were
higher than in the placebo trial, whereas the relative respiratory
exchange ratio was lower. There were no differences between both
tests in carbon dioxide production, expired volume or respiratory
rate.
All plasma data have been corrected with the haematocrite values
(Figure 1). Figures 2,
3 and 4 show plasma vitamin
E, A, and C levels, before and after the cycling tests, while Figure
5 shows changes in MDA before and after the trials. Vitamins
E and A, lipid soluble antioxidants, decreased significantly (p
< 0.05) in both strenuous situations independently of caffeine
ingestion (Figure 2 and 3),
whereas vitamin C, water soluble antioxidant, increased in both
tests with a more pronounced increase in the caffeine trial without
reaching significance (Figure 4).
Plasma MDA concentration as a measure of lipid peroxidation increased
(p < 0.05) similarly in caffeine and placebo tests without differences
between them (Figure 5).
While there were no urinary caffeine before, it was 5.61 ± 1.9 µg·ml-1
after exercise. Placebo samples had no caffeine concentration, while
caffeine samples were below the former limit of 12 µg·ml-1
imposed by the International Olympic Committee until year 2003.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Caffeine ingestion resulted in augmented exercise
performance as indicated by a significantly higher time to exhaustion
and maximal O2 consumption. These results are consistent with those reported
by other authors (Doherty and Smith, 2004; Flinn et al., 1990; Kaminsky et al., 1998). The ergogenic ability of caffeine has been explained
by increasing fat mobilization with the subsequent delay of muscle
glycogen utilization (Doherty, 1998) reflected in our study by the lower RER values, and also
could be explained either by a positive effect on the contractile
property of skeletal muscle increasing the capacity for work, reducing
leg muscle pain during exercise (O'connor et al., 2004)
or by delaying fatigue through the central nervous system mechanisms,
at least in part by blocking adenosine receptors (Doherty et al.,
2004).
Subjects increased plasma MDA levels after graded cycle exercise
until exhaustion on a cycle ergometer which means an increase of
lipid peroxidation. These results were in accordance with others
previously described in similar strenuous conditions (Ortenblad
et al., 1997)
and suggest the possibility of oxidative damage (Jammes et al.,
2004).
Since it has been reported that caffeine is a potent antioxidant
capable of preventing lipid oxidation (Devasagayam et al., 1996),
we expected lower values of MDA after the caffeine trial. Nevertheless,
a caffeine dose of 5mg/kg bw ingested 1 hour prior to the exercise
test does not seem to influence MDA production since there were
no differences between both trials.
Organism response to lipid peroxidation during exercise was reflected
with minor significant decreases on lipid soluble vitamins A and
E after maximal test in both experimental groups, as it has been
showed in other studies (Ortenblad et al., 1997;
Sacheck and Blumberg, 2001),
which indicates the consumption of plasma antioxidants protecting
the plasma lipids against damage (Jammes et al., 2004).
As Vitamin E can serve as a free radical scavenger and research
has shown an increase in its utilization following exercise (Mastaloudis
et al., 2001)
it is possible to think that this decrease could be attributable
to its actuation when other antioxidant systems are not capable of neutralizing oxygen
free radicals responsible for lipid peroxidation (Bowles et al.,
1991).
On the contrary, participants increased ascorbic acid plasma levels
after both cycle tests. These results agree with previous works
and they may have been due in part to a concomitant release of cortisol
and ascorbic acid from adrenal glands (Gleeson et al., 1987;
Umegaki et al., 2000)
or to the ascorbate recycling and efflux from neutrophils induced
by exercise (Tauler et al., 2002),
reflecting enhanced antioxidant defences in response to the oxidative
stress of exercise (Mastaloudis et al., 2001).
The inconsistent base values of vitamin C in the two test conditions
could be due to the complex metabolism of this substance after exercise
(Peake, 2003).
Despite randomisation of the tests, baseline vitamin C levels in
caffeine conditions may have been lowered by the exercise carried
out in the previously completed placebo test.
Nevertheless, a caffeine dose of 5mg·kg-1 bw ingested 1 hour prior
to the exercise test does not seem to have any influence on non
enzymatic antioxidant systems since there were no differences between
both trials. These results suggest that caffeine does not have any
influence on the oxidative stress in maximum incremental efforts.
The lack of caffeine in baseline urine samples indicates that only
caffeine permitted by the study was ingested. Urine data from the
caffeine trials show that a dose of 5 mg·bw-1 is permissible
with regard to the expired antidoping regulation of 12 µg·ml-1 caffeine
in urine.
Study limitations
This study was performed with a single dose of caffeine, so we can
not know how different dosages of caffeine should affect to oxidative
stress. Therefore, a suitable increase in oxidative stress could generate muscle damage. So for future studies,
different dosages of caffeine, higher and lower, must be considered
as a study of muscle damage markers.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
|
The
results of this study suggest that ingestion one hour prior to an
incremental cycling test of a 5 mg/kg body weight dose of caffeine
in subjects who do not usually perform exercise, allows them to
increase time to exhaustion, work load, maximum oxygen consumption,
as well as decreasing their respiratory exchange ratio. In spite
of this increased performance, the oxidative stress is not modified
by caffeine ingestion. We conclude that caffeine supplements at
doses of 5mg·kg-1 have no effect on oxidative stress derived from
maximum effort until exhaustion.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
-
Caffeine ingestion may improve maximal aerobic performance in
non trained men.
- Cellular
oxidative damage is not altered by caffeine ingestion in maximal
aerobic exercises.
- Antioxidant
response to exercise, vitamins A, E and C, is not modified by
caffeine action in maximal aerobic efforts.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Guillermo J. OLCINA
Employment: Lecturer and Vice-Dean of Coordination and International
Relations in Sport Science Faculty of University of Extremadura,
Spain.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Combat sport and cycling.
E-mail: golcina@unex.es |
|
Diego MUÑOZ
Employment: PhD studient in the University of Extremadura
Physiology Department, Spain.
Degree: MSc.
Research interests: Oxidative stress and exercise.
E-mail: diegomun@unex.es
|
|
Rafael TIMÓN
Employment: Lecturer in Sport Science Faculty of University
of Extremadura, Spain.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Exercise physiology and steroids.
E-mail: rtimon@unex.es
|
|
M. Jesús CABALLERO
Employment: Lecturer in Faculty of Medicine, Department
of Pharmacology.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Biochemical aspects of exercise,
caffeine and pharmacological topics.
E-mail: mcaballe@unex.es
|
|
Juan I. MAYNAR
Employment: Lecturer in Sciences Faculty, Department of
Analytical Chemistry and Electrochemistry.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Biochemical aspects of exercise.
E-mail: jimaynar@unex.es
|
|
Alfredo CÓRDOVA
Employment: Researcher in the University of Valladolid,
Spain.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Oxidative stress and exercise.
E-mail: a.cordova@bio.uva.es
|
|
Marcos MAYNAR
Employment: Lecturer of Exercise Physiology in Sport Sciences
Faculty, Department of Physiology.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Exercise physiologye.
E-mail: diegomun@unex.es
|
|
|
|
|