 |
| |
| Author | Year | Study type | Mean age (years) |
Minimum follow-up (months) |
Sample size | Graft type |
Index of clinical outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alentorn-Geli | 2010 | AM:26.4 TT27.5 |
24 | AM:26 TT:21 |
auto BPTB | LKS; IKDC(G); TAS; LT; PST; | |
| Azboy | 2014 | AM:27.6 TT:26.5 |
15 | AM:30 TT:34 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(G); TAS; LT; PST; | |
| Bohn | 2015 | RCT | AM:27.5± .2 TT:24.3±4.9 |
12 | AM:12 TT:11 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); IKDC(G); TAS; LT; PST; SSD |
| Cury | 2017 | AM:37.1±11.7 TT:31.4±8 |
24 | AM:30 TT:30 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); IKDC(G); LT; PST; | |
| de Areu-e-Silva | 2014 | AM:31.1±10.7 TT: 29.6±8.7 |
24 | AM:41 TT:30 |
auto Qua | LKS; IKDC(S); LT; PST | |
| Franceschi | 2013 | AM:29 TT:28 |
60 | AM:42 TT:46 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(G); LT; PST; SSD | |
| Geng | 2018 | RCT | AM:31.8±11.0 TT:29.6±11.7 |
12-37 | AM:56 TT:48 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; LT; PST; SSD |
| Guglielmetti | 2014 | RCT | <40 | 6 | AM:38 TT:35 |
auto STG | IKDC(G); LT; PST; |
| Hussein | 2012 | RCT | AM:32.6 TT:34.2 |
AM:50.5 TT:52 |
AM:78 TT:72 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); IKDC(G); PST; SSD |
| Kim | 2011 | AM:29.8 TT:30.3 |
12 | AM:33 TT:33 |
allo/auto BPTB | LKS; IKDC(G); LT; PST; SSD | |
| MacDonald | 2017 | RCT | AM:32.4±8.9 TT:30.7±9.3 |
24 | AM:46 TT:42 |
auto STG | IKDC(G); PST; SSD |
| Metso | 2020 | AM:34 TT:35 |
24 | AM:59 TT:57 |
auto STG | IKDC(G); LT; PST; | |
| Mirzatolooei | 2012 | RCT | AM:26.8 TT:26.6 |
18 | AM:80 TT:88 |
auto STG | LKS; LT; PST; SSD |
| Noh | 2013 | RCT | AM:22 TT:24 |
AM:22 TT:24 |
AM:31 TT:30 |
allo Ach | LKS; IKDC(G); LT; PST; SSD |
| Özer | 2018 | AM:28.17±5.61 TT:28.07±7.42 |
12 | AM:30 TT:30 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; LT; | |
| Razazadeh | 2016 | AM:30.0±6.5 TT:30.6±6.5 |
12 | AM:50 TT:44 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; LT; PST; | |
| Sukur | 2016 | AM:26.8 TT:25.5 |
24 | AM:56 TT:49 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; LT; PST; | |
| Taşdemir | 2015 | AM:29.04±7.53 TT:29.73±6.33 |
19 | AM:24 TT:15 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); LT; PST | |
| Wei | 2014 | AM:31.5 TT:33.4 |
12 | AM:42 TT:44 |
Auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); LT; PST | |
| Zehir | 2015 | AM:27.2±9.3 TT:28.3±8.8 |
12 | AM:71 TT:58 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(G); TAS; PST; SSD | |
| Zhang | 2012 | RCT | >28 | 12 | AM:31 TT:34 |
auto STG | LKS; PST; SSD |
| Hussin | 2018 | RCT | 16-39 | 12 | AM:30 mTT:30 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S) |
| Lee | 2014 | NR | 24 | AM:52 mTT:52 |
auto Qua | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; LT; PST; SSD | |
| Pande | 2017 | AM:31.16±7.73 mTT:29.35±7.95 |
24 | AM:43 mTT:49 |
auto STG | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; | |
| Sohn | 2014 | AM:26.9 mTT:29.8 |
AM:12 mTT:13 |
AM:20 mTT:20 |
allo TAT | LKS; IKDC(S); TAS; PST; | |
| Youm | 2014 | RCT | AM:27.6±9.9 mTT:29.7±11.9 |
19 | AM:20 mTT:20 |
allo Ach | LKS; IKDC(S); IKDC(G); TAS; LT; PST |