Table 3. Characteristics of included studies.
Author(s)/Country Purpose P SP CL D/R S DES L F Variables Main results Q
Alexander &
Luckman (2001)
Australia
Identify the teachers' perceptions and uses of the SE curriculum model T E/H Mx N Ma QT/NE - N Equity
Inclusion
Enjoyment

Greater emphasis on social skills;

SE is inclusive and promotes gender equity and enjoyment for students in physical education.

9
Alexander et al., (1996) Australia Report the Australian national trial of SE: Program change, educational impact, inclusivity, SE as a management tool T/St E/H Mx N Ma MIX/QE - N Leadership
Ownership
Equity
Teamwork
Peer-support

SE promoted a growing sense of ownership, cooperation, compliance, leadership, teamwork, peer support and equity.

Potential for gender marginalization.

8
Ang & Penney (2013) Singapore Explore the modification of the SE and utilization of pedagogical strategies to respond to students’ limited skills and abilities to handle failure in the context of PE. St E Mx N TS MIX/E 30 N Confidence
Resilience
Inclusion
Peer-support
Fair-play

Students’ physical self-concept and their ability to handle the stress from failure in PE were increased by the confidence- enhancing strategies used during the SE season;

Positive developments in students’ social and emotional skills.

12
Browne et al., (2004)
Australia
Examine the impact that two instructional approaches (traditional and SE) to teaching rugby had on students’ learning, enjoyment and affection. St M Sx
(Boys)
N TS MIX/QE 20 N Affiliation
Enjoyment
Responsibility
Autonomy

SE developed a greater feeling of community among their team;

Differences between groups were explained by the increased membership and feelings of belonging in SE.

14
Brunton (2003)
United Kingdom
See whether SE is a curriculum model that can successfully change power hierarchies in school PE. St H Mx N IS MIX/QE 20 N Responsibility
Teamwork
Engagement

Preference for responsibility expressed by female students

Team work was achieved through cooperative learning methods;

12
Burgueño et al., (2017)
Spain
Examine the influence of an intervention based on SEM, in comparison with Traditional Teaching Model, on motivational regulation in high school students in PE class. St H Mx N TS QT/QE 12 N Motivation

SE encouraged the development of the most self-determined regulations of motivation (intrinsic motivation and identified regulation) in teaching-learning process in school setting, which could arouse the interest of students for regular practice of sport in free time.

12
Calderón et al., (2010)
Spain
Analyze the initial implementation experiences of SE of a teacher and his students, in the elementary education. St E Mx N TS MIX/NE 14 Y Enthusiasm Engagement Affiliation
Satisfaction

SE developed a greater feeling enthusiasm and engagement;

Drawings revealed that students developed the sense of affiliation and satisfaction.

12
Calderón et al., (2013)
Spain
Compare the students and teachers’ perceptions after practice with different pedagogical models (SE and Traditional Style). St/T E Mx N TS QL/NE 8 Y Engagement
Enthusiasm
Satisfaction

Students referred greater feelings of satisfaction, enthusiasm and engagement.

12
Calderón et al., (2016)
Spain
Investigate the effect of shared teaching or co-teaching using the SEM in Primary, on the Social Climate Pre and post-intervention classroom. St E Mx N TS MIX/QE 10 N Teamwork
Satisfaction Autonomy
Engagement
Fair-play
Responsibility

The SE improved the Social Climate Classroom in the Primary sample object of study, favors the integration and teamwork, the students’ engagement and fair-play.

Carlson & Hastie (1997)
Australia
Examination of the social system as it occurred in a unit of SE. St/T H Mx N TS QL/NE 16 N Leadership
Trust
Responsibility Cooperation
Engagement Enjoyment
Fair-play
Inclusion

-SE increased the socialization due to increased interaction time;

Students spoke of cooperating, working as a team, learning to trust each other, fair-play and inclusion;

Facilitation of enjoyment within the SEM

Students who took referees roles viewed their refereeing as a positive experience with responsibility’ improvements.

9
Clarke & Quill (2003)
UK
SE as a vehicle to enhance learning aligned with the National Curriculum St M Mx N Ma QL/NE 44 N Inclusion
Autonomy
Leadership
Motivation Empathy
Ownership
Fair-play
Responsibility

Greater inclusion of less able students

Less teacher-dependent;

The pupils became valued team members and the more able pupils helped the less able to ensure the success of the team;

The pupils who took responsibility within the lesson became more involved in the learning process and demonstrated a strong sense of ownership and generally seemed more motivated and determined to succeed;

Pupils valued acceptable codes of behavior for competition.

8
Cuevas et al., (2015)
Spain
Analyze the impact of SEM in psychological basic need satisfaction in PE secondary students. St H Mx N TS QT/QE 19 Y Autonomy Social interactions

Improvements in the autonomy and satisfaction of the competence in the SE group;

Emphasized the suitability of the SEM to improve the satisfaction of psychological basic needs in PE.

13
Cuevas et al., (2016)
Spain
Analyze the impact of the SEM in self-determination and motivation, psychological basic need thwarting, enjoyment-satisfaction, boredom, and intention to be physically active in PE secondary school students in Spain. St H Mx N TS QT/QE 19 Y Motivation
Self-determination
Enjoyment

Significant improvements in intrinsic motivation in the SE group;

Emphasized the suitability of the SEM to improve self-determined behaviors in PE;

Changes were also observed in the satisfaction- enjoyment.

13
Curtner-Smith & Sofo (2004)
USA
Determine 15 American preservice teachers’ (PTs) conceptions of the teaching–learning process while teaching Sport Education and Multi-activity units during an early field experience. T M Mx N TS QL/NE 10 N Enjoyment
Ownership
Motivation

PTs found SE more attractive due to its compatibility with their occupational socialization and its cultural advantages;

PTs perceived that pupils “really enjoyed competition and games and being in a team”.

9
Farias et al., (2018)
Portugal
Examine students’ development of Game Performance and Game Involvement during participation in three consecutive SE seasons of invasion games. St/T M Mx N TS QT/QE 54 Y Engagement
Ownership

Improvements in Game Involvement in the second (handball) and third (football) seasons;

Students’ Game Involvement scores of handball and football were significantly higher than their scores while playing basketball;

The opportunity for an extended engagement in game-play activities and prolonged membership of students in the same teams throughout three consecutive seasons of SE were key to the outcomes found.

9
Fernandez-Rio & Menéndez Santurio (2017)
Spain
Assess students and teachers’ perceptions concerning their participation in an educational kickboxing learning unit based on a hybridization of two pedagogical models: Sport Education and Teaching for Personal and Social Responsibility. St/T H Mx N IS QL/NE 16 N Responsibility
Enjoyment
Cooperation
Affiliation
Friendship

Data produced 11 themes: responsibility, learning and roles, enjoyment, teaching, competition, cooperation and novelty, friendship, affiliation and transfer.

The hybridization of the two pedagogical models seemed to help increase both social and personal responsibility and to provide students with meaningful sporting experiences.

11
García-Lopez & Gutiérrez (2015)
Spain
Analyze the effect of a SE season on student empathy and assertiveness. St E/M Mx N TS QT/QE 18 N Assertiveness
Empathy

SE was shown to be a useful instructional model for improving a variable (assertiveness) directly related to personal and social responsibility. Group and team were key aspects when differences were significant.

10
García-Lopez et al., (2012)
Spain
Analyze the development of empathy, assertiveness and social relations that are usually attributed to this instructional model. St M Mx N TS QT/QE 18 Y Friendship
Engagement
Responsibility
Empathy
Assertiveness

Significant differences were found in increasing positive friends among the components of each team;

High levels of students’ engagement and responsibility to the performance of their duties both as referees and statisticians.

12
Gil-Arias et al., (2017)
Spain
Investigate the effect a hybrid TGfU/SE unit, in comparison to direct instruction, on Students' perceptions of various aspects of their motivation to engage in physical education St H Mx N TS QT/QE 8 Y Autonomy Enjoyment Empowerment

Students showed significant improvements in autonomy and enjoyment;

Students valued the empowerment by the teacher to solve specific tactical problems.

13
Gutierrez Diaz del Campo et al., (2014)
Spain
Analyze the viability of the SEM in the 2nd year of Elementary School, based on the analysis of the perceptions of teacher, and students. St/T E Mx N TS MIX/NE 10 Y Motivation
Inclusion
Affiliation

SE improved the inclusion;

Students revealed high levels of motivation and highlighted the affiliation.

10
Grant (1992)
New Zealand
Report the teacher perspectives of curriculum in terms of student gains. T H Mx N Ma QL/NE 22 N Ownership
Responsibility Inclusion
Cooperation
Enthusiasm
Decision-making
Teacher perceptions suggested that students:

Had considerable ownership and responsibility for what occurred at different stages of the program;

Helped establish realistic goals for the program;

Were valued members of a team;

Had an opportunity to share responsibility for and fully participate in all aspects of sport;

Were involved in decision making;

Were in situations where their presence and contributions were valued.

Revealed enthusiasm for competition

Promoted successful inclusion of lower skilled student.

7
Hastie (1996)
USA
Examine the student role involvement in SE. St M Sx
(Boys)
N IS MIX/NE 12 N Engagement
Responsibility
Ownership
Enthusiasm

High levels of student engagement with both playing and non-playing roles;

Student preference for responsibility and persistent team membership;

Students showed high levels of enthusiasm during their duty roles.

9
Hastie & Buchanan (2000)
USA
Analyze the combined SE-TPSR model. St M Sx
(Boys)
N TS QL/NE 26 N Responsibility
Empowerment
Problem-solving

The hybrid model was effective in facilitating personal responsibility, student empowerment and problem-solving;

Given the many opportunities to solve problems, the students were able to demonstrate a high degree of personal responsibility.

11
Hastie et al., (2014)
USA
Implement a SE season designed to be mastery involving and examine the degree of congruence between the objective measure of the presented climate with the students’ perceptions of the saliency of this motivational climate. St H Sx
(Boys)
N TS QT/NE 12 Y Satisfaction
Engagement
Autonomy

Consistent student perception of a mastery climate across all phases of the season;

Students’ perception of increased autonomy throughout the intervention;

The intervention caused improvements in engagement, satisfaction and perceived competence.

11
Hastie & Sinelnikov (2006)
Rússia
Examine the participation and perceptions of Russian students to SE St M Mx N TS MIX/NE 18 Y Engagement
Ownership
Enjoyment
Compliance
Empathy

Students of both genders and skill levels spent most of their lesson time actively engaged in motor tasks.

Students demonstrated significant competence in the officiating and coaching roles associated with the season.

Students commented that they found the season to be particularly interesting, that they enjoyed having student coaches and that they developed significant team affiliation.

Not only did the students show high levels of compliance with the attentional requirements of these roles, they also stated that officiating was enjoyable and ‘interesting’ but made unusual demands on students

12
Hastie & Sharpe (1999)
USA
Examine the effect of SE curriculum on prosocial behavior. St M Sx
(Boys)
Y
(At risk)
TS QT/QE 20 N Compliance
Friendship
Leadership

Formalized fair-play accountability system within formal competition phase increased compliance, reduced negative peer interactions and increased instances of leadership.

11
MacPhail et al (2004)
UK
Analyze year-5 students’ experiences of SE and the effects of membership of persisting groups on team affiliation. St E Mx N TS QL/NE 16 N Ownership
Confidence
Empathy
Friendship
Cooperation

The opportunity to become affiliated with a team was an attractive feature of the pupils’ PE experience and that, under the framework of SE, there was an obvious investment made by the students in relation to their sense of identity and involvement as members of a persisting group.

11
MacPhail et al (2008)
UK
Explore childrens’
experiences of fun and
enjoyment during SE.
St E Mx N TS MIX/NE 16 N Ownership
Enjoyment
Autonomy
Motivation

Students found the model to be fun and entertaining and developed the sense of affiliation and membership of a team.

Students’ perceptions of increased autonomy.

11
Méndez-Gimenez et al., (2015)
Spain
Compare the effects of three different instructional models: Traditional, Sport Education and Sport Education with Self-Made Materials on PE students' motivation and sportsmanship. St M/H Mx N TS QT/QE 12 N Friendship
Fair-play
Sportsmanship
Autonomy

SE seems to offer more advantages to develop achievement and social goals, as well as sportsmanship, of adolescents in PE.

SE groups showed significant increases in friendship goals;

SE groups reported improvements in autonomy,

Regarding fair play, significant improvements were also found in those groups that experienced SE.

11
Menéndez & Fernandez-Rio (2017)
Spain
Explore the impact of the combination of two pedagogical models, SE and Teaching for Personal and Social- Responsibility, for learners with disabilities experiencing a contactless kickboxing learning unit. St/T H Mx Y
(Disability)
IS QL/QE 16 Y Ownership
Enjoyment
Inclusion
Cooperation
Friendship

Data analysis resulted in three major categories: part of the team, learning and enjoyment.

The hybridization of SE and TPSR seems to be a powerful tool for including students with disabilities in PE, helping them and their classmates connect in and out of class.

Many students without a disability highlighted the importance of cooperative learning in this experience.

11
Meroño et al., (2015)
Spain
Analyze the effect of an intervention program based on Sports Education, on the perception of autonomy; the degree of enjoyment and perceived competence, and the degree of commitment; in a group of swimmers belonging to a sports club. A/C M/H Mx N IS MIX/QE 32 Y Autonomy
Enjoyment
Commitment
Motivation

Optimal behavior of the psychological variables of this study after the SE intervention;

Perception of autonomy of young athletes increased throughout the intervention;

Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation scores also showed no change from pre-post-SE.

13
Meroño et al., (2016)
Spain
Examine the effect of a Sport Education season on the technical learning of four swimming strokes and the perceived motivational climate. A/C M/H Mx N IS MIX/QE 32 N Motivation

The intervention program based on SE had a positive impact on improvement of swimming skill, and a more optimal motivational climate.

12
Mowling et al., (2006)
USA
Examine student drawings to determine what they perceived as most important during SE. St E Mx N TS QL/NE 20 N Affiliation
Responsibility
Engagement

Four key themes emerged:

(1) winning as a primary agenda; (2) a strong focus on affiliation and festivity; and (3) minimal representation of roles and responsibilities, (4) engagement.

12
Mesquita et al., (2016)
Portugal
Examine the perceptions of a physical education teacher and her students about the educational value of SEM regarding the development of competence, literacy and enthusiasm. St/T M Mx N IS QL/NE 20 N Autonomy
Equity Responsibility
Enthusiasm
Teamwork
Motivation
Engagement

Development of competent, literate and enthusiastic sportspersons;

Sense of autonomy, promoted by the balance between competition and inclusion, which also promoted literacy;

The enthusiasm was fostered by the interrelationship between the dynamics in cooperative work and the motivational climate generated having significant impact on students’ engagement in practice.

11
O’Donovan (2003)
UK
Analyze the effect of SE on student social goals and peer culture. St M Mx N Ma QL/NE 170 N Inclusion
Peer-support

SE promoted contact with peers from a variety of social groups and this provided an opportunity for these pupils to become affiliated to peers in ‘higher’ social groups and provided opportunities for pupils

to exert their position in the social hierarchy to influence the PE culture.

11
Perlman (2010)
USA
Examine the influence of Sport Education on amotivated students affect and needs satisfaction. St H Mx N TS QT/QE 15 Y Enjoyment Satisfaction

Amotivated students in SEM perceived higher levels of enjoyment and satisfaction than students taught by the traditional approach.

There was no difference in the need for autonomy and competence.

12
Perlman (2011)
USA
Examine the influence of the SEM on students’ self-determined motivation and underlying psychological need(s) in PE. St H Mx N TS QT/QE 20 Y Self-determination
Motivation

Changes in self-determination for students engaged in the SEM;

Implementation of the SEM may be utilized as a means for supporting students’ social connectedness and motivation to engage in sport-based activities.

12
Perlman (2012)
USA
Examine the perceptions and experiences of 33 amotivated students (during four consecutive seasons of the SEM. St H Mx N Ma QL/NE 12 Y Engagement

The features of team affiliation and a holistic game-play evaluation facilitated changes to amotivated students' perceptions of a sport-based physical education class.

11
Perlman & Goc Karp (2010)
USA
Examine the
perceptions of students and teachers from their experiences in two consecutive units of SE.
St/T H Mx N TS QL/NE 12 Y Self-determination
Fair-play
Inclusion

Structural aspects of SE assisted in facilitating movement along the self-determined continuum;

Students attributed being on a team throughout each season and implementation of a fair-play evaluation facilitated the sense of inclusion.

11
Pill (2010)
Australia
Explore a SE pilot project as a case study of the approach in a primary school setting. St/T M Mx N Ma QL/NE 10 N Equity
Responsibility
Motivation
Teamwork
Engagement

SE can deliver positive products for the class climate as well as for a student’s personal and social skill development in a primary school setting.

Enhanced levels of cooperation with peers, and a determination to be more equitable in participation during practice and play;

Students felt more included and motivated, and understood that they had developed skills for working cooperatively with others;

Enhanced feelings of motivation and inclusion.

11
Romar et al., (2016)
Finland
Describe and understand players’, coaches’ and parents’ perceptions and experiences of a soccer season when using the model in a Finnish junior sport club. A/C/Pa M Mx N TS QL/NE 11 Y Affiliation Enjoyment
Autonomy
Responsibility
Empowerment
Enthusiasm

Players affiliated within their teams, enjoyed having autonomy, responsibilities, had ‘fun’, enjoyed and spoke passionately about the experience;

Players valued the chance to make decisions and be responsible for their own actions.

11
Sinelnikov and Hastie (2008)
Rússia
Study the ecology of SE in one Russian school. St H Mx N TS QL/NE 18 Y Responsibility
Ownership
Fair-play
Empowerment
Enjoyment

Students enjoyed being part of a team and developed a strong sense of belonging;

During officiating, students were concerned about not giving an advantage to any particular team;

Fun was derived from being part of the team and from the authentic competition;

Students reported increased levels of responsibility and decision-making during the season.

12
Sinelnikov and Hastie (2010)
Russia
Measure and describe the objective motivational
climate of a Sport Education season conducted in a Russian school.
ST H Mx N TS QT/QE 18 Y Motivation

SE had more mastery-oriented and less performance-oriented teacher behaviors.

The objective motivational climate of skill practice and practice competition phase had more of a mastery-oriented climate.

11
Smither & Xihe (2011)
USA
Examine high school students’ experiences in a Sport Education unit being implemented with smaller teams and fewer roles. St/T H Mx N TS QL/NE 280 N Engagement
Autonomy
Problem- solving

Transformation of students into more active learners through team autonomy and problem solving within the team;

The smaller teams with few roles appeared to lead to higher engagement, especially for less skillful students.

11
Spittle & Byrne (2009)
Australia
Investigated the influence of SE on student motivation. St M Mx N TS QT/QE 10 N Motivation

Difference were found between the conditions on changes in perceived competence, task orientation, and mastery climate, with the traditional condition decreasing significantly from pre- to post-test compared with SE.

12
Tindall (2013)
Ireland
Provide a detailed description of post primary students’ reactions to a disability awareness experience using extended contact theory, SE and the disability sport of sit-volleyball as the framework. St H Sx
(Girls)
Y TS QL/NE 16 N Enjoyment
Empathy (experience)

Participating in a disability sport was found to be favorable amongst the students;

Students expressed an interest in further disability sport experiences as part of their regular PE curriculum.

11
Vidoni & Ward (2009)
USA
Examine the effects of fair-play instruction on student social skills during SE. St M Mx N TS QT/QE 18 N Engagement
Enjoyment
Fair-play

Fair-Play instruction was effective in increasing students’ active participation, and in decreasing waiting time for all participants;

students enjoyed participating in the study because they had fun with that.

11
Wallhead et al., (2010)
USA
Analyze the effects of SE on students’ voluntary participation in a lunch-time recess sport club. St E/H Mx N TS QT/QE 24 Y Motivation

Autonomy supportive curriculum models, such as SE, may have the potential to facilitate transfer of motivation and participation in PA from a physical education to an extracurricular context.

12
Wallhead & Ntoumanis (2004)
UK
Analyze the changes in student motivation as a result of SE. St H Sx
(Boys)
N TS QT/QE 6 N Enjoyment Engagement
Motivation

Increases in SE student enjoyment and perceived effort;

Perceptions of task involving climate explained increases in student motivational indices.

11
* P= participants, St= students, T= teachers, A= athletes, C= coaches, Pa= parents, SP= school population, E= elementary, M= middle school, H= high school, CL= classes, Sx= single-sex, Mx= mixed-sex, D/R= disabled or at-risk students, Y= yes, N= no, S= sport, TS= team sports, IS= individual sports, MA= multiactivities, DES= study design, QL= qualitative, QN= quantitative, MIX= qualitative and quantitative, E= experimental, QE= quasi-experimental, NE= non-experimental, LS= length of the Sport Education season (number of lessons), F= fidelity of the Sport Education model, Q= methodological quality of the study.