Research article - (2010)09, 239 - 244 |
Differences in Physical Fitness and Cardiovascular Function Depend on BMI in Korean Men |
Wi-Young So1, Dai-Hyuk Choi2, |
Key words: Body mass index, obesity, physical fitness, cardiovascular function |
Key Points |
|
|
|
Subjects |
Subjects were 2013 Korean male adults over the age of 20. Subjects visited a health promotion center at Yang-Cheon Gu, Seoul and took a comprehensive medical and fitness test between 01-01-2006 and 12-31-2009. Subjects who consumed drugs or had a history of stroke, cancer, heart failure, angina, or myocardial infarction were excluded from the study. |
Experimental procedures |
Subjects' height and weight was measured, and body mass index (BMI) was calculated from these results. The study used the WHO's Asia-Pacific standard of obesity: BMI<23 = normal, 23≤BMI<25 = overweight, BMI≥25 = obese (WHO/IASO/IOTF, Fitness assessment of cardiorespiratory endurance, muscular strength, muscular endurance, flexibility, power, agility, and balance were evaluated by VO2max (ml·kg-1·min-1), grip strength (kg), sit-ups (reps/min), sit and reach (cm), vertical jump (cm), side steps (reps/30s), and standing on one leg with eyes closed (sec), respectively. The maximal oxygen consumption (VO2max) was obtained from YMCA submaximal test using a cycle erogometer (Helmas SH-9600K, Korea). Through gradual increase of the exercise intensity which was started 150kgm for 3min and increased via YMCA protocol, the maximal oxygen consumption (VO2max) was estimated (Golding, Grip strength was evaluated by recording the average (of three measurements) full-strength power (kg) generated by subjects using a grip strength dynamometer (Helmas SH-9600D, Korea), which was adjusted to the second knuckle of their fingers. The number of sit-ups performed in a 60 second period was recorded for subjects lying on a sit-up board (Helmas SH-9600N, Korea), using their upper body only with their knees bent at right angles and both hands held behind their necks. For the sit and reach test, subjects sat on a flexibility measuring instrument (Helmas SH-9600G, Korea) with their heels positioned at the edge and their knees pointed upwards, and they bent forward at the waist with their hands outstretched to push the measuring instrument; the test was administered three times, and the average value was recorded. Subjects performed a vertical jump three times on a vertical jump board (Hermas SH-9600F, Korea), and we recorded the average value in cm. The side step was measured as follows. Subjects stood on a board (Helmas SH-9600J, Korea) with a midline (white) in the center of the board. On either side of the midline was a parallel line (white) 100 cm from the midline. Initially, subjects stood with both feet on the midline. They stepped rightwards until their right foot crossed the right line. Next, they stepped leftwards until their leftfoot crossed over the midline, and they returned to the original posture on the midline. Next, they stepped leftwards until their left foot crossed the left line. To complete the maneuver, they returned to the midline. They repeated this maneuver for 30 s, and the total frequency of repeated maneuvers was determined. To assess the ability to stand on one leg with eyes closed, subjects closed their eyes and stood on one leg on a balance measuring instrument (Helmas SH-9600H, Korea); we administered the test three times and calculated the average time (s) until the second foot touched the ground. For cardiovascular function, we evaluated systolic blood pressure (SBP), diastolic blood pressure (DBP), resting heart rate (RHR), double product (DP), and vital capacity. After subjects rested comfortably for at least 10 minutes, a nurse practitioner measured SBP and DBP using a sphygmomanometer (Alpk, Japan) at the right brachial artery. These values were measured three times, and the average values were determined. Resting heart rate was determined by attaching a heart rate sensor (Polar S610, Finland) to a subject’s chest for one minute. DP was determined by SBP X HR. A vital capacity measuring instrument (Helmas SH-9600C, Korea) was attached to subject’s mouth, and the maximum exhalation value was determined after a deep breath. |
Statistical analysis |
All results from this study are shown as the average and standard deviation. To determine the difference in fitness and cardiovascular function between BMI groups (normal group, overweight group, and obese group), we used one-way ANOVA and administered a post-hoc test to determine noted differences related to groups. All analyses were performed using SPSS version 12.0 software (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA). Statistical significance levels were calculated: p < 0.05, p < 0.01 and p < 0.001. |
|
|
Subject characteristics |
Subject characteristics are shown in |
The relationship between BMI and health-related physical fitness |
The relationship between BMI and health-related physical fitness is shown in |
The relationship between BMI and motor-related physical fitness |
The relationship between BMI and motor-related physical fitness is shown in |
The relationship between BMI and cardiovascular function |
The relationship between BMI and cardiovascular function is shown in |
|
|
TAs a person becomes more obese, the body becomes less sensitive, further limiting the scope of everyday activities. This physical inactivity in turn leads to the habit of remaining seated while working. Thus, it is natural to expect that an obese person would have a lower fitness level. However, most of the existing studies restricted the key evaluation parameters of fitness level to VO2max, which is an indicator of cardio-respiratory endurance (Meyers et al., Among health-related physical fitness parameters, cardio-respiratory endurance was low for the obese group at almost every age, which agrees with results from previous studies (Meyers et al., Of the motor-related physical fitness parameters, power and balance were shown to be lower for the obese group compared to the normal group. However, there was no statistically significant difference in agility. Since power is defined as force multiplied by speed (Vivian, Obesity stimulates the sympathetic nervous system as hyper-insulinemia develops and sodium accrues. This stimulated sympathetic nervous system increases the risk of hypertension (Mikhail et al., Obesity stimulates the sympathetic nervous system as hyper-insulinemia develops and sodium accrues. This stimulated sympathetic nervous system increases the risk of hypertension (Mikhail et al., The limitation of this study is rooted in the use of cross-sectional methodology. The study therefore only clarifies the correlation between obesity and physical fitness; it does not demonstrate a causal relationship between the two. Also, the data are not representative of all Korean men since the participants only resided in Seoul. However, the large number of subjects (2,000) is a primary merit of this study compared to others. When extended to a cohort study, this study may provide a solid base for more in-depth research investigating the correlation between obesity, physical fitness, and cardiovascular function for Koreans and other Asians. |
|
|
The obese group had a lower fitness level, including cardiorespiratory endurance, power, and balance, but the obese group demonstrated an increase in muscular strength. In addition, we found that the obese group had higher blood pressure and weaker cardiovascular function, including DP and vital capacity, than the normal group. |
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY |
|
REFERENCES |
|