The main pursuit of this study was to assess the effect of post-dehydration drinking of waters with various temperatures on fluid balance in Taekwondo athletes. The temperatures were described by the subjects as cold (5°C), cool (16°C), tepid (26°C) and warm (58°C). Therefore, this investigation set out to test the effect of these feelings on voluntary drinking of water. These temperatures are commonly used in daily life as refrigerated water (5°C), cool tap water (16°C), water approximately at room temperature (26°C), and water at the temperature of a hot drink e.g. coffee (58°C). As shown statistically, intake of subjects was normally distributed, which means they consumed similar amounts of water intra-experimentally. The highly significant difference in the amount of water intake inter-experimentally brings emphasis on the fact that water temperature is an important factor in the determination of voluntary drinking. Boulze et al., 1983 report that water temperature is the main factor in short term water intake. Most previous studies, however, have investigated the effects of ‘forced’ hydration by instructing subjects to drink specific amounts and, unfortunately, there has been little investigation on voluntary drinking which naturally occurs during or after exercise (Butudom et al., 2004). The water temperature at which the highest voluntary intake occurred was 16°C. This is almost the same figure reported by Boulze et al., 1983 (15°C). Similarly, the Office of Surgeon General has recommended 16°C for field drinking water (Sandick et al., 1984), and American College of Sports Medicine recommends that ingested fluids be cooler than ambient temperature, between 15 degrees and 22 degrees C (Convertino et al., 1996). Boulze et al., 1983 also reports that when subjects were asked to mix their preferred temperatures, they chose 14.9+/-1 °C. These are inconsistent with the findings of Sandick et al., 1984 that reported more voluntary drinking of 5°C water than 16°C water. Adolph et al. (1947) have shown that soldiers in the desert with two bottles of 13°C and 28°C water or 15°C and 43°C prefer 13°C and 15°C. This, again, shows the fact that human subjects in hot environments prefer cool water but they have not tested any preference for water below 13°C (cold water). In a study on dehydrated normothermic horses it was shown that they preferred water at 20°C (near ambient temperature) more than 10°C and 30°C (Butudom et al., 2004). The study has assessed no temperature between 10°C and 20°C, so, 20°C in this study could be considered close to both 16°C and 26°C in the present investigation. Also, the fluid used in the study of horses was 0.9% saline and authors discussed the effect of temperature on the taste of saline. To induce consuming a greater volume of beverages, their composition together with their palatability should be taken into account when free choice is given to individual, as indeed occurs in most situations (Maughan et al., 1997). Human subjects have reported less salty taste when the temperature of the solution rose to 22°C, so horses may prefer saline at 20°C because it has less salty taste (Butudom et al., 2004; McBurney et al., 1973). Palatability is commonly referred to pleasing flavor of the drink, but a classic study defines palatability as flavoring and cooling the drink, and demonstrates that both increase voluntary drinking (Szlyk et al., 1989). Temperature preference in human adults seems to have its own special aspects. Human newborns stop sucking more often and for longer periods with cold milk than with warm milk (Makoi et al., 1978). Interestingly, horses showed a tendency to take fewer longer drinks in 20°C saline than 10°C and 30°C (Butudom et al., 2004) which shows a similarity to newborns. Preference for cooler water by adult humans differs from human newborns and rats so it may be a learned behavior because humans have daily access to cold water (Butudom et al., 2004; Boulze et al., 1983). A dehydrated subject who is hyperthermic due to heat exposure is up against the challenge of thermal state and fluid state, thus he desires cold drink to provide both fluid and heat sink. Cool or cold drinks ingested during and after exercise can act as a heat sink and lower core temperature (Wimer et al., 1997), thus having a soothing effect on hyperthermia. It seems the bodily systems involved tend to render a balanced response in dealing with these two alterations, i.e. helping the extirpation of surplus temperature and improving altered fluid state by intake of water. This is probably why according to Boulze et al., 1983 resting humans prefer water at 20°C. Our subjects drank less cold (5°C) water. Cold water has been described as both more pleasurable and less drunk by Boulze et al., 1983. They have shown that although colder water is preferred following exercise, offering a progressively colder drink (<10°C) can actually decrease volume consumed. As a result, hyperthermia, rather than dehydration, seems to be a more important mechanism for the preference for colder water. It has been established that coldness of the drink has a satisfying effect on thirst (Guyton and Hall, 2006). In the study on athletic horses it is concluded that greater satiation of thirst by oropharyngeal cooling may have contributed to lesser intake of colder fluid (Butudom et al., 2004). Gastric emptying is slower for cold solutions than for warm solutions (Deaux, 1973). As gastrointestinal distention may partially alleviate thirst (Guyton and Hall, 2006), intake of cold water could prolong satiation by slowing gastric emptying rate (Butudom et al., 2004) thus decreasing voluntary drinking. And finally it seems intolerable to intake a great quantity of cold water which has a temperature much different from body temperature. It follows that drinking cold water seems to provide thermal needs at the expense of fluid needs. Contrary to the commonly held view, cold water (~5°C) does not induce more voluntary drinking and better hydration status. Our subjects showed the least voluntary drinking in warm water (58°C). Drinking warm water seems both intolerable because of the temperature difference, and unpleasant for its excess thermal load. Intake in 5°C trial was significantly correlated with Posm change induced by dehydration. The correlation between intake and Posm change was insignificant in other trials. In a study on horses water intake was reported to be significantly correlated with the increase in plasma sodium concentration induced by administration of oral electrolyte pastes (Dusterdieck et al., 1999). Posm seems to affect voluntary drinking, but why the correlation is insignificant in trials other than 5°C is not yet clear. The borderline correlation of intake and the subject’s weight loss in 16°C trial and 58°C trial shows some possible relationships across these parameters. It has been reported that voluntary fluid intake and subjective rating of thirst were related to body weight loss during exercise (Mack et al., 1986). Sandick et al., 1984 reported a significant positive correlation between amount of 5°C water drunk and weight loss (r = 0.66, p < 0.005). Intake of water at the other temperatures (16, 22, 38°C) was not significantly correlated with the subject’s weight change in their study. |