The main purpose of this study was to identify and analyze the motivational profiles of high school students including satisfaction, importance and usefulness that the students give to the subject of PE. In addition the relationship between those profiles and the variable of gender and with the number of hours spent practicing sport and physical activity in their free time was analyzed. The results of this study confirmed the existence of three motivational profiles that corroborated patterns similar to those extracted in a cluster analysis with two random sub-samples. The three motivational profiles were based on the level of self-determination (high, low and moderate or intermediate) (Boichè et al., 2008; Moreno et al., 2006; Ntoumanis, 2002). Furthermore, Cox and Ullrich-French, 2010 also found three profiles they called "positive", "weak" and "mixed". Additional studies found only two profiles of "high" and "low" motivation (Vlachopuolos et al., 2000; Yli-Piipari et al., 2009). The three profiles found in this study, will be referred to as "moderate motivation", "low motivation" and "high motivation". The results of this study have important theoretical implications and expand the knowledge base about students’ motivations, their satisfaction and the importance they place on PE. As shown by the data, high school students’ motivation was primarily intrinsic, scoring low on amotivation and high on satisfaction / fun. Moreover, these students had a goal orientation toward the task. Studies that have examined the Achievement Goals Theory related to motivational profiles and motivational variables have found that task-orientation is associated with fun, intrinsic motivation and the belief that the student’s success depends on effort and interest, while ego-orientation is associated with negative emotional feelings such as boredom, concern about the outcome or dissatisfaction (Walling and Duda, 1995). The results show the positive relationship between intrinsic motivation and task-orientation, confirming the results obtained in different studies on PE which also reveal a positive motivational climate to the task with self-determined motivation (Moreno et al., 2006; Moreno-Murcia et al., 2013; Standage et al., 2003). In general, this is a subject highly valued by students, hence the high values obtained in satisfaction / fun and low in boredom. Satisfaction / fun was positively associated with the importance attached to PE since, as stated by Mendoza et al., 1994, most students feel that they really like PE classes and considered it an important subject. These data corroborate those of Moreno and Cervello (2003) who found 90.1% of students surveyed, considered PE an important subject. Looking at the data from cluster 3, (high motivation) (n = 910 students), it can be seen that these students are motivated towards PE, they have fun, are oriented to the task and also place high importance to PE. Cluster 1- moderate motivation-showed the highest values of ego orientation, coinciding with one of the profiles identified by Moreno et al., 2006, with the lowest values in task orientation and extrinsic motivation. These results agree with those reported by Moreno-Murcia et al., 2013 and Ntoumanis and Biddle, 1999, who state that teachers who during their teaching promote an ego oriented climate foster poor school performance due to lack of self-determined motivation, even reaching levels of boredom or discouragement. This is the opposite of what would happen in cluster 3, where a motivational climate that involves the task develops intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. In fact, in this study we can see how lack of motivation is positively correlated with boredom and negatively with fun and task orientation, qualities more characteristic of cluster 3. Moreover, cluster 2 of this study, - low motivation-, obtained high positive values in amotivation and boredom, and low in intrinsic motivation, fun and importance and usefulness of PE. This means that the students least motivated towards PE express less interest in the practice of physical and sports activities (Moreno and Cervelló, 2003). The data obtained in cluster 1 of this work, which generally includes males who practise for less than 3 hours a week are in line with the above. It can also be seen how in clusters 1 and 2 there are high values of amotivation and boredom, while in cluster 2 we found low levels in and intrinsic motivation and importance given to PE. These results are in line with the profiles found by Ntoumanis, 2002, who obtained higher data of boredom and amotivation in the moderate motivation and controlling motivation/amotivation profiles. Moreover authors such as Boichè et al., 2008 associate amotivation with the moderate motivational profile as well as that of low motivation (Yli-Piipari et al., 2009). But in our analysis it can also be appreciated that these data are accompanied in both profiles by less than 3 hours per week playing sport, a finding that agrees with Moreno et al., 2006, namely, that when students do not perform much physical activity in or outside school they tend to have similar values to clusters 1 and 2. Moreover, these authors argue that, in contrast, attitudes are more positive towards PE when the student feels more motivated, does physical activity out of school and practices more often. These statements corroborate the data obtained in cluster 3. These data can equally be explained from the Hierarchical Model of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation (Vallerand, 1997; 2001) so that if students have positive experiences during PE classes (situational) they may develop positive attitudes towards PE (contextual) and therefore commit them to practicing weekly physical exercise (global). Nevertheless, several authors found that the students’ assessment of PE classes (García Ferrando, 1993; Torre, 1997) was not very positive, as the student was aware that much time was lost in class, few hours were in fact spent doing PE and sport, and hence these students gave little importance to this subject. Carreiro Da Costa et al., 1997 and Cervelló, 1999 examined motivation in PE, concluding that the most motivated students enjoy classes, like to practise sports activities, are more involved in tasks and even grant greater importance to this subject, and it can be said that the results of this study are consistent with the results of those authors. Cluster 3 (high motivation) shows the highest values corresponding to intrinsic motivation, satisfaction, fun, task-orientation, importance of PE and extrinsic motivation. These data support the contributions of Biddle et al., 1995, Goudas, 1998, and Walling and Duda, 1995, who suggest that most self-determination profiles relate to a perception of climate that involves the task and in turn these students grant more importance to PE (Moreno-Murcia et al., 2013). In fact, Vlachopoulos et al., 2000 obtained a profile with these characteristics, in which students had high scores on both types of motivation (intrinsic and extrinsic), high values in the practice of extra-curricular physical activity and attached great importance to PE. The high motivation profiles obtained by Yli-Piipari et al., 2009 were characterized by very high values of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, while the so-called positive profile of Cox and Ullrich-French, 2010 show a high level of self-determination, fun, effort and practicing physical activity outside school. Jimenez (2003) analyzed the relationship between motivational climate, healthy lifestyles and extracurricular sports, finding that when teachers fostered a motivational climate that rewarded effort, active participation and personal autonomy, it was positively related to a more favorable assessment of PE classes and increased extracurricular sports. The data found in cluster 3 corroborate these findings. Similarly, Moreno and Cervelló, 2003 found that students who play some extracurricular sports found more enjoyment in formal PE classes, not wanting to change the subject for any other. Cluster 3 is positively associated with males, agreeing with Moreno et al., 1996 and Moreno and Cervelló, 2003 who state that males have a greater preference for PE and sport than females. According to Macdonald, 1990 and Lirgg, 1993 this may partly be due to the fact that girls receive less positive feedback than boys, do not have the same opportunities to engage in these activities, the fact that teachers encourage boys more strongly than girls and girls probably perceive this difference in treatment (Cervelló et al., 2004). The subjects in this profile exercise for more than 3 hours a week. This means that these students have, in addition to school PE classes, at least additional 3 hours per week of physical activity and sport. The highest the number of sessions per week, the best is the students’ evaluation of the subject of PE (Moreno and Cervelló, 2003). This study supported previous findings that students who perform extracurricular sports, show more pleasure and value PE classes more than those students who don’t (Moreno et al., 2002a; 2002b). In this regard, several studies show that self-determined motivation is positively related to greater commitment, adherence to sport, effort and persistence (Ferrer-Caja and Weiss, 2000; Moreno et al., 2007; Standage et al., 2003). Other aspects of this profile may also possibly strengthen this adherence. Casimiro, 1999 and Cervelló and Santos-Rosa, 2000 found that students like most and give greater importance to PE than to all other subjects, finding the highest scores among elementary students rather than among high school students, and more among boys than girls. In fact, cluster 3 showed that when boys attach great importance and usefulness to PE that they are more likely to make up the hours that they need for PE, they practiced more than 3 hours a week. Finally, it is interesting to note the gender analysis in each of the profiles, as well as the results that show that highest values of satisfaction / fun and importance of PE are among the high motivational profiles and are linked to doing physical exercise and sport outside school. Teachers should think about these findings when planning PE lessons, so that they are in line with the interests of today’s boys and girls, improving satisfaction, fun, and the importance of the subject, thereby fostering long-lasting physical and sporting habits. Based on the results of the variables included in the high motivation profile in Table 5, presenting the relationship by gender and hours of practice outside school, we propose the following aspects to promote adherence to exercise and sport regularly outside school PE: a) Selection of content covered in the classroom, taking into account the current interests of adolescents, particularly girls, may increase their motivation in PE classes. To increase students’ interest in physical activity thereby greater satisfaction in PE by transferring that interest to their leisure activities. b) The teacher plays an important role not only in content selection, but also in treatment of students in the classroom to raise the importance and usefulness of PE among students. When the teacher encourages a motivational climate towards the task, student motivation may well be increased, as well as fun and their enjoyment of classroom practice. This may increase the number of components associated with cluster 3 (high motivation). c) Analyze the school’s environmental context (extracurricular activities, beach, mountains, etc.) so that the content covered in class can be continued by students outside school for as many hours as possible. d) Increase and improve the feedback given to girls, to try to improve their liking of PE since boys typically receive more positive feedback boys from the teacher. This preference is clearly seen in the cluster 3 with the boys. |