Research article - (2018)17, 279 - 288 |
Creatine Supplementation Supports the Rehabilitation of Adolescent Fin Swimmers in Tendon Overuse Injury Cases |
Imre Juhasz1,, Judit Plachy Kopkane2, Pal Hajdu3, Gabor Szalay3, Bence Kopper4, Jozsef Tihanyi4 |
Key words: Tendinopathy, pain, therapeutic strategy |
Key Points |
|
|
|
Participants |
The participants of this study were injured adolescent male and female competitive fin swimmers (n = 18; male = 10, female = 8; years = 15.1 ± 1.5, range: 12-18 years; body mass = 60.8 ± 8.9, range: 50.5-82.5 kg; height: 1.71 ± 0.06 range: 1.59-1.84 m). The subjects were randomly assigned to the Cr (CR; n = 9, male = 5, female = 4; years = 15.5 ± 1.4) or placebo (PL; n = 9, male = 5, female = 4; years = 14.8 ± 1.6) group with a double-blind research design. The subjects were given Cr supplementation (CR), or received placebo (PL) as part of the conservative treatment of the soft tissue (tendinopathy of the FHL). We calculated the biological age of the subjects using methods of Mészáros et al. ( |
Experimental conditions |
The acute phase of tendinopathy treatment was carried out at the homes of the injured participants in line with the specialist requirements. The recovery and maintenance phase of the rehabilitation exercise program was carried out independently according to the instructions of a physiotherapist. Treatment is based on sound principles but was individualized to suit particular needs. The physiotherapy exercises and methods were used identically in both groups for all subjects. The physiotherapist was the same in every case. Individual nutrition was compiled by a nutritionist for all subjects during treatment. The subjects kept a treatment log. |
Tendinopathy treatment plan |
Physical examination was performed under clinical conditions. The physical examination included inspection for muscle atrophy, asymmetry, swelling, erythema, and joint effusions. Range-of-motion testing was often limited on the symptomatic side. If the diagnosis was unclear, additional imaging procedures were performed. All subjects were diagnosed with subacute (the duration of symptoms 4-6 weeks) FHL tendinopathy due to overuse (Mueller-Wohlfahrt et al., Subjects were instructed not to take part in any other treatments such as non-steroidal analgesic and anti-inflammatory drugs, or ultrasound during treatment. The subjects signed informed consent forms agreeing with the requirement. |
Creatine supplementation protocol |
The definition of Cr supplementation was adjusted to reference (Kreider et al, |
Direct Segmental Multi-Frequency Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (DSM-BIA) |
We measured the segmental lean mass (SLM; kg) of the injured limb with the DSM-BIA (Bartels et al., |
Experimental procedure for the measurement of Plantar Flexion Torque (PFT) |
A custom-made dynamometer measured the ankle plantar flexion isometric peak torque. The dynamometer consisted of an aluminum plate, and two alloy aluminum single point load cells (type: AG100; Lorenz Messtechnik GmbH, Alfdorf, Germany), which were placed below the plate. The non elastic strap with metal reinforcement was pulled through the aluminum plate, and was fixed to the load cell. The nominal force which was measured by the device (combination of two load cells) is 2000 Newtons (N); its precision is 1 N and its resolution is 0.1 N. The dynamometer was easily portable (since its weight was less than 3 kg with small external dimensions 40 × 40 × 10 cm). The transducer signal was conditioned with an electronic board equipped with an onboard analogic low pass filter (cut-off frequency: 10 Hz). A digital screen could either continuously display the force or retain the maximal value in the flexion direction. The subjects were seated on a chair adjusted to the height of the subject in order to obtain a right angle at the hip, knee and ankle joints. The feet were held flat on the dynamometer. For ankle plantar-flexion measurement, the strap was placed and held distally on the thigh and passed directly over the external malleolus. The subject was asked to pull against the strap by extending his ankle while pushing with the sole of their foot while trying to lift the heel. The experimental setup for maximum PFT measurements is shown in Subjects were verbally encouraged to produce their maximal ankle plantar-flexion strength. Two trials were recorded, consisting of two 2-4 second maximal contractions separated by a 30 second rest period. If the relative difference between these two maximal voluntary contractions (MVC) was within 10%, no additional trials were required. If not, additional trials were proposed as long as two reproducible MVCs were obtained. The maximum value of the two reproducible trials was retained for further analyses. The peak torque was computed. The experimental conditions were the same in all cases. Two independent evaluators performed the measurement to assess reliability. |
Numeric rating scale for pain assessment |
Instructions (McCaffery and Beebe,
|
Blood sampling and metabolite measurements |
Creatine kinase (CK) was assessed before the immobilization (baseline), and then every 24 hours for four days. Every time, before sampling, subjects sat quietly for 5 minutes. For serum CK, blood was drawn from the antecubital vein into a 10 mL collection tube via a Vacutainer apparatus. The blood samples were allowed to clot at room temperature for 10 minutes and centrifuged for 15 minutes. Serum was separated and frozen at -20°C for subsequent analysis. Total CK was determined by Beckman DU 640 spectrophotometer (Beckman Instruments, Inc., Fullerton, CA, US) in duplicate, at 25°C, using a commercial test kit (Labtest, Sao Paulo, Brazil). |
Statistical analysis |
Because of the complexity of the study, the limited number of subjects available with similar injury and the basis of previous studies using similar number of subjects, we concluded that for the purpose of determining statistical significant differences the limited sample size will be sufficient. All statistical computations were run on the measured raw datasets. The Shapiro-Wilk’s W test was carried out for each variable for normality. All of the variables were normally distributed. Fisher’s exact test was used to compare the homogeneity of the variances. Two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was applied when the effect of the immobilization and the rehabilitation program was tested (specifically for PFT a 2x3, for DSM-BIA and for NRS a 2x4 and for CK a 2x5 model was used for the comparison of the measured data). Repeated measures ANOVA was used to compare values within the groups, and also on the basis of the repeated measures ANOVA results intraclass correlation coefficient-ICC, standard error of measurement-SEM and minimal difference-MD, was calculated for CR and PL, to verify the reliability of the procedure, in accordance with Vincent and Weir ( |
|
|
Direct Segmental Multi-Frequency Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (DSM-BIA) |
After two weeks of relative immobilization of the injured leg, the SLM significantly decreased (p < 0.01) in both groups. The SLM decreased by 8.9 ± 0.9% (-0.65 ± 0.09 kg) in PL and by 5.6 ± 0.5% (-0.43 ± 0.05 kg) in CR, respectively. We found a significant difference (p < 0.05) between the two groups after immobilization (statistical analysis was calculated using a 2X4 ANOVA, interaction between groups: F=57.47, p < 0.01). The next four weeks of the active rehabilitation program increased the injured leg’s SLM in both groups. During the four weeks active rehabilitation period, we detected a significant increase of 5.5 ± 0.6% in the CR group (+0.4 ± 0.04 kg; p < 0.01), and also a significant, but lower growth of 3.8 ± 0.8% in the PL group (+0.25 ± 0.06 kg; p < 0.01), compared to the values after the immobilization. After the 4-week period of active rehabilitation, the SLM was significantly different from baseline in PL (-0.4 ± 0.04kg; p < 0.01). In contrast, CR group reached a state of baseline. We found a significant difference (p < 0.01) between the two groups after four weeks of active rehabilitation. For CR ICC = 0.99, SEM = 0.86kg, MD = 2.37kg; for PL ICC = 0.99, SEM=0.58kg, MD = 1.6kg ( |
The Plantar Flexion Peak Torque (PFT) |
The PFT (Mmax; N |
Numeric Rating Scale (NRS; 0-10) for pain assessment |
The pain intensity (NRS) was measured on a scale ranging from 0-10. Before the immobilization (Baseline), and after the acute (R2), recovery (R4) and maintenance (R6) phase of rehabilitation. The pain intensity was significantly lower two weeks after relative immobilization (Baseline-R2; decreased by 64.4 ± 9.6%; p < 0.01), after the recovery (Baseline-R4; decreased by 93.1 ± 8.2%; p < 0.01) and the maintenance (Baseline-R6; decreased by 98.4 ± 4.8%; p < 0.01) phases of the active rehabilitation in the CR group. The result in the PL group was about the same but the decrease of pain intensity happened in a slower pace during the experimental periods (Baseline-R2; decreased by 57.7 ± 9.4%; Baseline-R4 by 72.4 ± 8%; Baseline-R6 by 88.8 ± 9.6%; p < 0.01). In the percentage change there was a significant difference between groups during active rehabilitation (statistical analysis was calculated using a 2X4 ANOVA, interaction between groups: F = 6.39, p < 0.01). Significantly faster decrease were found in the CR group during rehabilitation versus the PL group (CR vs PL; R2-R6; 94.4 ± 16.7% vs. 75 ± 20.4%; p < 0.02). For CR ICC = 0.14, SEM = 2.49, MD = 6.88; for PL ICC = 0.88, SEM = 0.81, MD = 2.25 ( |
Creatine Kinase (CK) |
In the CR group the CK significantly elevated by 3.2 ± 1.7% (p < 0.01) during the first 24 hours, then significantly decreased by 10.1 ± 7.1% (p < 0.01) during the next three days. In the PL group the CK significantly increased further by 12.9 ± 5.3% (p < 0.01) during the first two days, then significantly decreased by 9.3 ± 3.1% (p < 0.00) during the next two days. A significantly relative difference was found 48 hours after the beginning of treatment between the experimental groups (CR vs PL; 24 – 48 hours; -0.1 ± 1.7% vs. +6.0 ± 3.1%; p < 0.01). We observed no significant difference in CK (U/L) levels between the two groups (statistical analysis was calculated using a 2X5 ANOVA, interaction between groups: F=13.82, p < 0.01) before the start of treatment (CR vs PL; Baseline = 444.2 ± 184.3 vs. 428.9 ± 146.8), and 24 (456.4 ± 453.8 ± 149.9), 72 (445.7 ± 181.3 vs. 464.8 ± 155.3) 96 (410.3 ± 192.2 vs. 437.0 ± 149.3) or hours after the beginning of treatment. For CR ICC = 0.99, SEM = 3.48 U/L, MD = 9.6 U/L; for PL ICC = 0.99, SEM = 5.44 U/L, MD = 15.01 U/L ( |
|
|
Our paper presents a novel research on the effect of Cr supplementation on regeneration periods in tendon overuse injury rehabilitation of adolescent fin swimmers. The results in our present study demonstrate that a therapy-strategy combined with Cr supplementation efficiently supports the tendinopathy rehabilitation of adolescent fin swimmers. It moderates the muscle and strength loss during rehabilitation after injury; decreases pain intensity and significantly shortens the entire rehabilitation period. The limitation of this study is the small sample size. However, our results give some preliminary basis for further research. Relatively little data is available regarding young athletes’ Cr consumption. We know that more and more athletes under 18 years of age use Cr supplements for the purpose of physical enhancement (Evans et al., Compared to the number of writings about the swimmers’ motion system damage, we found only a few studies that discussed the active motion system injuries affecting fin swimmers, their causes and treatment options (Sereni et al, The lower limb muscles and tendons provide the primary propulsive force in fin swimming. The muscles and tendon injuries are primarily due to overuse and wrong technical implementation. The identification and accurate diagnosis, the treatment and rehabilitation of adolescent athletes, requires more than just conservative treatment and rest. There is evidence that young athletes better and more quickly regenerate after muscle and tendon injury (Best, The FHL muscle is the strongest muscle among the deep digital flexor muscles, is involved in plantar flexion, supination and approximation of the foot (Langley et al., The preservation of the skeletal muscle mass plays an important role in the rehabilitation of muscle and tendon damage. In our study, which supports the results of previous studies (Cooke et al., The gains in body mass observed are likely due to water retention during supplementation. Cr is an osmotically active substance. Thus, any increase in the body's Cr content should result in increased water retention (Hultman et al., Because Cr is primarily stored intramuscularly (95%), it is more likely that the increase in TBW would be intracellular because of the direct influx of water into the muscle cell. Increase in cell volume appears to be an anabolic proliferative signal, which may be the first step in muscle protein synthesis (Haussinger et al., In this present study we have not examined TBW content. It is also important to know that the BIA method is very sensitive to the change in this indicator, and even with a slight increase in TBW, this results in a higher SLM. Our results suggest that Cr supplementation attenuates the muscle mass loss, and also supports the faster recovery of muscle size. Larger mass and more muscle fibers would potentially have a greater total capacity to store and exploit ingested Cr (Brault and Terjung, After any injury of muscle or delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS), the force generation capacity of the muscle decreases. The reason of this force reduction is partly due to the pain that inhibits the muscle to exert maximum force. Unfortunately, we do not have data about the maximum strength of the FHL, that could have been observed before injury, to estimate the force reduction caused by the tendinopathy. In our study, the torque increased almost linearly during the immobilization in both groups that can be attributed to the decreasing pain. As the rate of force increase is similar in both groups, we cannot state that Cr supplementation caused this elevation in torque. During therapy, both groups increased further torque production, but CR enhanced force with greater rate than PL did, which may be the consequence of Cr supplementation. We first investigated the pain intensity change of overuse tendon damage to alternative treatment strategy in adolescent fin swimmer cases. After two weeks of immobilization, the pain decreased in both groups, but swimmers in the CR group reported significantly less pain. Actually, the CR group had only minor pain after the two-week therapy program, which disappeared by the end of the experiment. The PL group recovered slower and the difference was significant in all measurements between the two groups. Previous studies suggest that Cr supplementation reduces the increase of inflammatory cytokines concentration (Bassit et al., The most widely studied marker of muscle damage induced by physical exercise is CK (Brancaccio et al., It is noted that the application of the CK enzyme as a damage marker in sports medicine received several criticisms because of the large variability within and among individuals, and there is a diversity in gender, and sports activities (Hortobagyi and Denahan, Muscular overuse is associated with structural damage of the contractile elements and reflected in DOMS. Mechanical overstress is supposed to be the major contributing factor for inducing muscle damage. The initial damage is followed by an inflammatory response and eventually by regeneration. Calcium is assumed to play an important role in triggering the inflammatory changes (Kuipers, Thus, ingestion of exogenous Cr may provide protective effects via increased phosphocreatine synthesis which, in turn may aid in stabilizing the sarcolemma membranes and thereby reducing the extent of damage. The presumed anti-inflammatory effect of Cr behind the mechanisms is not known. Further research is needed to clarify the possible systematic effects on muscle Cr. |
|
|
Altogether, the observations presented in our paper indicate that Cr supplementation combined with therapeutic strategy effectively supports the rehabilitation of tendon overuse damage of adolescent fin swimmers. Our results suggest that the Cr supplementation, combined with specific therapy, is a good way to accelerate the recovery of the injured tendons and ligaments. Furthermore, it can be assumed that oral supplementation of Cr applied in the most severe training periods, may prevent overuse injury, i.e. tendinopathy. |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
We appreciate the athletes’ patience, perseverance, and the possible unpleasant test procedures that made it possible to conduct the study. Thanks to Eva Kalman and Zoltan Guba for providing language help. Thanks to Tracy Lloyd and Paul Illand for language proofreading. IJ designed the study, oversaw data collection, data analysis and manuscript preparation. JPK assisted with study design, data analysis and manuscript preparation. PH assisted with designing the study, manuscript preparation and statistical analysis. GSZ assisted with manuscript design and helped to draft the manuscript. BK assisted with statistical analysis. JT assisted with study design, data analysis and manuscript preparation. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript, and agreed with the order of presentation of the authors. None of the authors declare competing financial interests. This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors. The research was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Eszterhazy Karoly University. The studies were conducted in accordance with the declaration of Helsinki. Each participant and parent gave their written, informed consent after explanation of the study purpose, experimental procedures, possible risks and benefits. All the volunteers signed a free and informed consent term before participation. |
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY |
|
REFERENCES |
|