Letter to editor - (2004)03, 57 - 59 |
The Prevalance of Exercise Induced Bronchoconstriction in Elite Athletes |
Mehmet Ünal1, Türker Şahinkaya1, Deniz Namaraslı1, Vakur Akkaya2, Abidin Kayserilioglu1 |
Dear Editor-in-Chief |
For years exercise induced bronchoconstriction (EIB) has been considered as a form of asthma which can be provoked by exercise and air pollution. However, further studies indicated that EIB was not only restricted to asthmatic patients, but could also be seen in healthy individuals. EIB was described as an acute and reversible bronchoconstriction induced 5 to 15 minutes after exercise in certain susceptible individuals (Rundell and Jenkinson, The incidence of EIB is more than twice as high among athletes (11-50%) compared to the normal population (4-20%) (Anderson and Daviskas, The study population consists of 126 male elite athletes (85 soccer players, 25 karateist, 11 swimmers, and 5 wrestlers) (height 177 ± 9 cm, weight 73 ± 10 kg, age 23 ± 5 years). Before exercise testing and warm-up, the athletes were informed in detail about the tests. Respiratory function test was carried out on a Spirobank Spirometer (Mir, Roma, Italy). All the tests were performed under the following ambient conditions: humidity 40% to 45%, temperature 20°C to 25°C, atmospheric pressure 750 to 760 mmHg. The athletes performed the test three times and the best result was taken into consideration. After performing the respiratory function tests, athletes exercised on a treadmill (Quinton 65) according to the Bruce protocol (Quinton-5000). The speed and the grade of the treadmill increased every 3 minutes according to the protocol until the exhaustion. Electrocardiography (ECG) and blood pressure were continuously monitored, as oxygen uptake was being measured with the “breath by breath” system (Sensor-Medics 2900C, USA) during the test. The preferred method of diagnosing EIB is by observing changes in airways following the exercise testing. As EIB becomes evident 5 to 15 minutes after exercise, respiratory function tests are applied 5, 10 and 15 minutes after maximal tests. The most valued parameters in the diagnosis of EIB are >10% decrease in forced expiratory volume 1 second (FEV1), >15% decrease in forced expiratory flow from 25% to 75% (FEF25-75%) and peak expiratory flow (PEF) (Rundell and Jenkinson, Repeated measures were tested with the ANOVA test, while statistical differences between the groups were analyzed using the independent samples t-test. P < 0.05 was accepted as significant. In the present study, it was observed that 11% (n=14), 14% (n=18), and 11% (n=14) of the athletes had >10% decrease in FEV1, >15% decrease in FEF25-75%, and >15% decrease in PEF respectively ( Voy ( The EIB depends on the rigor and duration of exercise, the humidity and temperature of the testing environment. To provoke EIB; the duration of exercise should be at least 6 to 8 minutes, exercise intensity should aim to rise heart rate over 85% of the maximal heart rate (MHR) in sedentary individuals and 95%-100% of the MHR in athletes (Anderson and Daviskas, The prevalence of EIB (11-14%) for the elite athletes participated in this study is similar to the results of previous studies. Nysland et al. ( Although, EIB is reversible at the early stages, it progresses to become irreversible by time. This may be due to a remodeling of the surface epithelium of the small airways. Therefore, winter sports athletes show 78% higher rate of EIB compared to summer sports athletes, although the levels of exercise and endurance are similar, and they are tested in corresponding surroundings (as in humidity 50%, temperature 21°C), and under the same work load (Rundell and Jenkinson, The main limitation of studies in this area seems to be the method to provoke EIB. In a study by Rundell and Jenkinson ( Thus, it is concluded that 11% to 14% of the elite athletes have EIB when they are tested in laboratory conditions. However, there is no statistical difference in athletic performance (exercise duration and VO2peak) between the groups. Nevertheless, further studies are needed to test athletes in the field and to examine whether the mechanisms may differ between atopic and non-atopic individuals and how airway remodeling affects EIB. |