Letter to editor - (2011)10, 233 - 234 |
Reliability and Accuracy of 10 GPS Devices for Short-Distance Exercise |
Julen Castellano1, David Casamichana1, Julio Calleja-González1, Jaime San Román1, Sergej M. Ostojic2 |
Dear Editor-in-Chief |
The use of GPS technology for training and research purposes requires a study of the reliability, validity and accuracy of the data generated (Petersen et al., Nine trained male athletes participated in the study. Each participant completed 7 and 6 linear runs of 15 m and 30 m, respectively (n = 117), with only one GPS device being used per participant. Each repetition required them to complete the route as quickly as possible, with 1 min recovery between sets. Distance was monitored through the use of GPS devices (MinimaxX v4.0, Catapult Innovations, Melbourne, Australia) operating at the above mentioned sampling frequency of 10 Hz. In addition, all tests were filmed with a video camera operating at a sampling frequency of 25 frames. Data were collected during what were considered to be good GPS conditions in terms of the weather and satellite conditions (number of satellites = 10.0 ± 0.2 and 10.3 ± 0.4 for sprints of 15 m and 30 m, respectively). Distance was measured using a tape measure. Electronic timing gates (TAG- Heuer, CP 520 Training model, Switzerland) were used to obtain a criterion sprint time accurate to 0.01 s, with gates being placed at the beginning and end of the route (Petersen et al., The accuracy of data within and between devices is shown in The intra-device reliability is depicted in To our knowledge this is the first study to assess the reliability and accuracy of GPS devices operating at a sampling frequency of 10 Hz. A further point of note is that studies of intra- and inter-device reliability for the same model of device (and therefore the same sampling rate) have traditionally used only two devices (Duffield et al., The distance data were found to be highly accurate and only slightly underestimated by the GPS devices. Furthermore, high intra- and inter-device reliability was observed. Accuracy improved with increased distance, and the mean SEM of 10.9% when running 15 m was reduced by half over 30 m ( As regards intra-device reliability, high values were obtained in all cases, and increased when used over 30 m ( |