Table 2. Characteristics of included studies.
Author(s)/Country Purpose P SP CL S DES L F Variables Main results Q
Browne et al., (2004)
AUSTRALIA
Examine the impact that two instructional approaches (TT and SE) to teaching rugby had on students’ learning, enjoyment and affection. St M Sx
(Boys)
TS MIX/QE 20 N Student Learning
Enjoyment
Affect

Both groups made significant improvements in their knowledge of the game as well as their skill.

The interview data provide repeated references that suggest the clear majority of students from both classes enjoyed their unit, regardless of the way it was taught.

SE students expressed an increased feeling of ownership and commitment to the process as well as increased feeling of being part of a team.

12
Burgueño and Medina-Casaubón (2020)
SPAIN
Examine the influence of SE on sportsmanship orientations in high school students. St H Mx TS QT/E 16 Y Sportsmanship

Significant improvement of four of the five sportsmanship orientations (i.e., respect for social conventions, respect for rules and referees, full commitment, and respect for opponents) after a SE season.

13
Burgueño et al., (2018)
SPAIN
Examine the influence of SE on basic psychological need satisfaction in the sport teaching-learning process that takes place in PE. St H Mx TS QT/QE 12 Y Basic psychological needs
(Autonomy
Competence
Relatedness)

SE significantly improved the levels of autonomy, competence and relatedness need satisfaction in the inter-group analysis and in the intra-group analysis.

13
Burgueño et al., (2017)
SPAIN
Examine the influence of an intervention based on SE, in comparison with TT, on motivational regulation in high school students in PE class. St H Mx TS QT/QE 12 N Situational motivation (intrinsic motivation, identified regulation, external regulation, and amotivation)

SE group increased significantly in intrinsic motivation, identified regulation and decreased amotivation, external regulation

TT group increased in external regulation and amotivation and decreased in intrinsic motivation and identified regulation

13
Cuevas et al., (2015)
SPAIN
Analyze the impact of SE in psychological basic need satisfaction in PE secondary students. St H Mx TS QT/QE 19 Y Basic psychological needs (Autonomy, Competence and Relatedness)

Significant improvements in competency for SE group; TT group decreased.

Increased in autonomy and relatedness for both groups but not significantly.

13
Cuevas et al., (2016)
SPAIN
Analyze the impact of the SE in self-determination and motivation, psychological basic need thwarting, enjoyment-satisfaction, boredom, and intention to be physically active in PE secondary school students in Spain. St H Mx TS QT/QE 19 Y Motivational regulation (intrinsic motivation, identified regulation, introjected regulation, external regulation, and motivation)
Psychological need thwarting (thwarting competence, thwarting autonomy, thwarting relatedness)
Intention to be physically active
Satisfaction-enjoyment
Boredom
Self-determination

Significant improvements in intrinsic motivation in the SE group.

Although changes were not found to be significant for the other variables: slight improvements were noted in self-determination and identified regulation in the SE group; small changes were observed in the satisfaction- enjoyment and need thwarting of competence variables in the SE group.

13
Fernandez-Rio et al., (2013)
SPAIN
Examine the effects of three instructional approaches in secondary education students’ physical self-concept after the implementation of an ultimate learning unit. St H Mx TS QT/QE 12 N Physical self-concept

Students in the TT and SE groups increased their physical self-concept from initial to final tests, but not significantly.

13
Hastie et al., (2013)
PORTUGAL
Examine the relative effectiveness of 2 forms of PE instruction on students’ skill and technical performance, as well as content knowledge in 3 track and field events. St H Mx IS QT/QE 20 Y Technical performance
Content knowledge

Although both groups improved significantly their technical performance from pretest to posttest, the SE classes outperformed the TT classes in both technique and skill execution.

Only the SE group made significant improvements in content knowledge.

13
Hastie et al., (2009)
USA
Investigate changes in students’ aerobic fitness levels following a season of SE. St M Mx IS QT/QE 15 N Aerobic Fitness Levels

SE group with higher increases than TT group; significant differences between both models (TT group with small improves).

13
Kao (2019)
CHINA
Analyze the impact of a SE unity on team cohesion (within effect), and compare team cohesion between a TT method and a SE unit (between effects). St U Mx TS QT/QE +20 N Team Cohesion (teamwork, team adaptation, interpersonal interaction)

SE group made significant improvements on team cohesion after the course; all post-test scores were higher than those for the TT group;

TT group did not notice significant improvements on team cohesion or any subscale.

12
Luna et al., (2020a)
SPAIN
Evaluate the impact of an educational intervention on social competence and social acceptance among adolescent. St H Mx TS QT/E 16 N Social competence
Peer social acceptance

SE group presented more significant improvements in some indicators of social competence and social acceptance among peers than those obtained with the TT.

14
Luna et al., (2020b)
SPAIN
Evaluate the impact of a physical-SE pilot programme on adolescents’ subjective well-being (health-related quality of life, positive and negative affect), trait emotional intelligence and social anxiety St M Mx TS QT/QE 18 N Subjective well-being (positive affect and negative affect)
Psychosocial adjustment (depression, anxiety and social stress)

SE group had significant improvements in the affective component of subjective well-being and a reduction in anxiety.

13
Parker & Curtner-Smith (2005)
USA
Compare the health-related fitness benefits for pupils participating in SE and traditional multiactivity (MA) units of instruction. St M Mx TS QT/QE 10 Y Physical activity

Students in the MA unit spent slightly more than the recommended 50% of lesson time in moderate to vigorous physical activity (MVPA) while the pupils in the SE unit did not approach this level.

11
Méndez-Gimenez et al., (2015)
SPAIN
Compare the effects of three different instructional models: TT, SE and SE with Self-Made Materials on PE students' motivation and sportsmanship. St M/H Mx TS QT/QE 12 N Achievement goals (mastery approach, performance approach, performance avoidance, mastery avoidance)
Friendship
Basic psychological needs (autonomy, competence and relatedness)
Fair-play (sportsmanship)
SE group presented:

Significant increases in autonomy, competence and relatedness.

Significant increases in friendship.

Significant increases in performance-avoidance goals.

Significant increases in social conventions, rules and officials, and opponent.


TT group:

Increased but not significantly in performance avoidance-goals, in friendship avoidance.

Increased significantly in rules and officials, but not significantly in social conventions and opponent.

Increased significantly (less than SE group) in autonomy and competence (not in relatedness)

13
Pereira et al., (2016)
PORTUGAL
Examine the effects of SE and Direct Instruction on students’ content knowledge in three track and field events (hurdles, triple jump, and shot put) considering their gender and skill level. St M Mx IS QT/QE 20 Y Student knowledge

Significant knowledge improvements in both instructional approaches irrespective of students’ gender and skill level.

12
Pereira et al., (2015)
PORTUGAL
Examine students’ technical performances improvements in three track and field events (hurdles, shot put, and long jump) following either a SE season or a Direct Instruction unit. St M Mx IS QT/QE 20 Y Technical performance

SE students of both genders and skill levels improved significantly in all events.

Direct Instruction group presented significant improvements but limited to boys and students of higher skill level.

12
Perlman (2010)
USA
Examine the influence of Sport Education on amotivated students affect and needs satisfaction. St H Mx TS QT/QE 15 Y Basic psychological needs (autonomy, competence and relatedness)
Enjoyment

Amotivated students in SEM perceived higher levels of enjoyment and satisfaction than students taught by the traditional approach.

Significant differences between groups for relatedness, with significant improvements for SE group

There were no differences in the need for autonomy and competence.

Both groups presented decreases on these variables, from pre- to post-test.

13
Perlman (2011)
USA
Examine the influence of SE on students’ self-determined motivation and underlying psychological need(s) in PE. St H Mx TS QT/QE 20 Y Self-Determined Motivation (Intrinsic Motivation, Identified Regulation, External Regulation and Amotivation
Basic Psychological needs (Autonomy, Competence and Relatedness)

Significant differences on the self-determination index between groups, with higher improvements for students in SE group.

Significant differences between groups for relatedness, with significant improvements for SE group.

Lack of significant differences between groups for autonomy and competence;

TT group presented increases only on competence.

13
Perlman (2012)
USA
Examine the physical activity differences between amotivated students engaged in the SE compared with a TT sportbased physical education class. St H Mx TS QT/E 15 Y Physical activity levels

Engagement within the SE provided amotivated students with an increased opportunity to engage in higher levels of physical activity.

13
Pritchard et al., (2008)
USA
Study the effects of SE and the TT instructional approaches on skill development, knowledge, and game performance of the sport of volleyball. St H - TS QT/E 20 Y Technical performance
Student Knowledge
Game Performance
Game involvement

No significant difference between models for technical performance (SE group increased in all skills, TT group did not in setting skill).

No significant difference between models for knowledge and game involvement (both variables increased).

Significant differences between models for game performance with increases for SE but decreases for TT.

13
Rocamora et al., (2019)
SPAIN
Assess the effects of two instructional approaches, SE and Direct Instruction (DI) on students’ physical activity intensity levels, game performance, and friendship goals. St M Mx TS QT/E 15 Y Physical activity
Game performance
Friendship

Sedentary PA levels were significantly higher in the DI group.

Light and moderate PA levels were significantly higher in the SE group.

Increased values for SE group in friendship-approach and friendship-avoidance goals

In the DI group, only girls increased significantly in friendship-avoidance goals.

Significant gains in both study groups for game performance, but larger in the SE group.

13
Segovia & Gutierrez (2020)
SPAIN
Evaluate the effects on schoolchildren’s body composition of a game-based high intensity interval training. St M Mx TS QT/QE 15 N Body composition
(waist circumference and body
fat percentage)

GB-HIIT is effective in modifying the body composition of primary school children. However, the methodology used to implement the GB-HIIT program (SE or TT) had no impact on the findings.

12
Spittle & Byrne (2009)
AUSTRALIA
Investigate the influence of SE on student motivation. St H Mx TS QT/QE 20 N Intrinsic motivation (enjoyment/interest, effort/importance, perceived competence, and pressure/tension)
Goal orientations (task orientations and goal orientation) Perceived motivational climate (performance climate and mastery climate)

Significant difference between the conditions on changes in perceived competence, task orientation, and mastery climate, with the Traditional condition decreasing significantly from pre- to post-test compared with the SE condition.

No significant differences between conditions on interest/enjoyment, effort/importance, pressure/tension, ego orientation, or performance climate.

12
Viciana et al., (2020)
SPAIN
Examine the effect of a PE-based SE program on personal and interpersonal variables, social environment, and the predisposition of acquiring positive habits and autonomy in high-school students in order to assess the contribution of this model to the students. St H Mx TS QT/E 12 N Motivation
Satisfaction
Perceived physical fitness
Effort and improvement
Relatedness
Cooperative learning
Classroom climate
Sportsmanship
Intention to be physically active
Autonomy

Compared with the TT group, SE participants had a statistically significant increase in self-determined motivation toward PE, satisfaction toward sport, physical self-concept, relatedness with others, cooperative learning, classroom climate, sportspersonship, autonomy and acquisition of habits (autonomy support, and the intention to be physically active).

13
Wahl-Alexander & Chomentowski (2018)
USA
Determine changes in college-aged students’ aerobic fitness levels following participation in a university physical conditioning course. St U Mx IS QT/QE 26 Y Physical activity levels

Students who participated in the SE condition experienced significantly greater improvements in the number of PACER laps when compared to the TT group. In addition, students in this same condition significantly decreased their one-mile run time during their enrolment in this course.

12
Wallhead & Ntoumanis (2004)
UK
Determine the effect of SE and TT approach, to teaching a unit of games-based activity in physical education. St H Sx
(male)
TS QT/QE 8 N Enjoyment
Perceived effort
Perceived competence
Motivational climate
Autonomy

Students in the SE curriculum group reported significantly higher postintervention enjoyment and perceived effort than those taught with the TT.

11
Wallhead et al., (2014)
USA
Examine the effect of a high school-required program taught using SE on students’ perceived effort and enjoyment in physical education, physical activity intentions, and leisure-time physical activity. St H Mx TS QT/QE 25 N Student Learning enjoyment affect

SE participants reported greater increases in perceived effort and enjoyment than did the students taught within the TT.

Limited support for the direct transfer of motivation from a sport education program to increases in leisure-time physical activity behavior.

11
Xu, Gao & Xu (2019) CHINA Investigate the impact of SE on students’ skills and attitudes in table tennis course in high school. St H - IS MIX/QE 16 N Table tennis skills
Students’ attitudes

Both classes (SE and TT) made significant improvements in their skills, while SE students made more progress in forehand drive and serve than TT students did.

13
P = participants, St = students, T = teachers, SP = school population, M = middle school, H = high school, U = university, CL = classes, Sx = single-sex, Mx = mixed-sex, S = sport, TS = team sports, IS = individual sports, DES = study design, QN = quantitative, MIX = qualitative and quantitative, E = experimental, QE = quasi-experimental, LS = length of the Sport Education season (number of lessons), F = fidelity of the model, Q = methodological quality of the study.